![[PDF]](/pb-assets/Icons/adobe-pdf-icon.png){kind=icon}
Abstract
Welfare sanctions are financial penalties applied to individuals who fail to comply with welfare program rules. Their widespread use reflects a turn toward disciplinary approaches to poverty management. In this article, we investigate how implicit racial biases and discrediting social markers interact to shape officials' decisions to impose sanctions. We present experimental evidence based on hypothetical vignettes that case managers are more likely to recommend sanctions for Latina and black clients—but not white clients—when discrediting markers are present. We triangulate these findings with analyses of state administrative data. Our results for Latinas are mixed, but we find consistent evidence that the probability of a sanction rises significantly when a discrediting marker (i.e., a prior sanction for noncompliance) is attached to a black rather than a white welfare client. Overall, our study clarifies how racial minorities, especially African Americans, are more likely to be punished for deviant behavior in the new world of disciplinary welfare provision.
REFERENCES
Section:
| Agency for Workforce Innovation (AWI). 2004, January 21. “Final Guidance: Welfare Transition Program Work Penalties and Pre-Penalty Counseling” (AWI FG 03-037). Google Scholar | |
| Alport, Gordon.1954. The Nature of Prejudice. Cambridge, MA: Addison-Wesley. Google Scholar | |
| Ayres, Ian, Siegelman, Peter.1995. “Race and Gender Discrimination in Bargaining for a New Car.” American Economic Review 85: 304–21. Google Scholar, ISI | |
| Bertrand, Marianne, Mullainathan, Sendhil.2003. “Are Emily and Greg More Employable than Lakisha and Jamal? A Field Experiment on Labor Market Discrimination.” Poverty Action Lab Paper #3. Retrieved July 20, 2007 (http://povertyaction-lab.org/papers/bertrand_mullainathan.pdf). Google Scholar | |
| Blalock, Hubert M. 1967. Toward a Theory of Minority Group Relations. New York: Wiley. Google Scholar | |
| Bloom, Dan, Winstead, Donald.2002. Sanctions and Welfare Reform. Welfare Reform and Beyond Initiative Policy Brief #12. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution. Retrieved October 10, 2007 (http://www.mdrc.org/publications/191/policy-brief.html). Google Scholar | |
| Boehmke, Frederick J. 2005. DURSEL: A Program for Duration Models with Sample Selection (Stata version). Version 2.0. Iowa City, IA: University of Iowa. Retrieved September 3, 2007 (http://myweb.uiowa.edu/fboehmke/methods). Google Scholar | |
| Boehmke, Frederick J., Morey, Daniel S., Shannon, Megan.2006. “Selection Bias and Continuous-Time Duration Models: Consequences and a Proposed Solution.” American Journal of Political Science 50: 192–207. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Bonds, Michael.2006. “The Continuing Significance of Race: A Case Study of the Impact of Welfare Reform.” Journal of African American Studies 9: 18–31. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Born, Catherine, Caudill, Pamela, Cordero, Melinda.1999. “Life After Welfare: A Look at Sanctioned Families.” Baltimore, MD: University of Maryland, School of Social Work. Google Scholar | |
| Botsko, Christopher, Snyder, Kathleen, Leos-Urbel, Jacob.2001. “Recent Changes in Florida Welfare and Work, Child Care, and Child Welfare Systems.” New Federalism: National Survey of America's Families, State Update no. 2. Washington, DC: Urban Institute. Google Scholar | |
| Cho, Chung-Lae, Kelleher, Christine A., Wright, Deil S., Yackee, Susan Webb.2005. “Translating National Policy Objectives into Local Achievements across Planes of Governance and among Multiple Actors: Second-Order Devolution and Welfare Reform Implementation.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 15: 31–54. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Correll, Sherry, Benard, Stephen, Paik, In.2007. “Getting a Job: Is There a Motherhood Penalty?” American Journal of Sociology 112: 1297–1338. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Crenshaw, Kimberle.1991. “Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence Against Women of Color.” Stanford Law Review 43: 1241–99. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Darley, John M., Gross, Paget H..1983. “A Hypothesis-Confirming Bias in Labeling Effects.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 44: 20–33. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Devine, Patricia G., Baker, Sarah M..1991. “Measurement of Racial Stereotype Subtyping.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 17: 44–50. Google Scholar, SAGE Journals, ISI | |
| Dias, Janice Johnson, Maynard-Moody, Steven.2007. “For-Profit Welfare: Contracts, Conflicts, and the Performance Paradox.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 17: 189–211. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Duster, Troy.2008. “Introduction to Unconscious Racism Debate.” Social Psychology Quarterly 71 (1): 6. Google Scholar, SAGE Journals, ISI | |
| Eberhardt, Jennifer L., Davies, Paul G., Purdie-Vaughns, Valerie J., Johnson, Sheri Lynn.2006. “Looking Deathworthy: Perceived Stereotypicality of Black Defendants Predicts Capital Sentencing Outcomes.” Psychological Science 17: 383–86. Google Scholar, SAGE Journals, ISI | |
| Fording, Richard C., Soss, Joe, Schram, Sanford F..2007. “Devolution, Discretion, and the Effect of Local Political Values on TANF Sanctioning.” Social Service Review 81: 285–316. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Fox, Cybelle.2004. “The Changing Color of Welfare? How Whites'Attitudes towards Latinos Influence Support for Welfare.” American Journal of Sociology 110: 580–625. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Gilens, Martin.1999. Why Americans Hate Welfare: Race, Media, and the Politics of Antipoverty Policy. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Goldberg, Heidi, Schott, Liz.2000. “A Compliance Oriented Approach to Sanctions in State and County TANF Programs.” Washington, DC: Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Google Scholar | |
| Goldrick-Rab, Sara, Shaw, Kathleen M..2005. “Racial and Ethnic Differences in the Impact of Work-First Reforms on Access to Postsecondary Education.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 27: 291–307. Google Scholar, SAGE Journals, ISI | |
| Gooden, Susan Tinsley.2003. “Contemporary Approaches to Enduring Challenges: Using Performance Measurement to Promote Racial Equality under TANF.” Pp. 254–78 in Race and the Politics of Welfare Reform, edited by Schram, S. F., Fording, R. C., Soss, J.. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. Google Scholar | |
| Hancock, Ange-Marie.2004. The Politics of Disgust: The Public Identity of the Welfare Queen. New York: New York University Press. Google Scholar | |
| Hancock, Ange-Marie.2007. “When Multiplication Doesn't Equal Quick Addition: Examining Intersectionality as a Research Paradigm.” Perspectives on Politics 5: 63–79. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Hasenfeld, Yeheskel, Ghose, Toorjo, Larson, Kadyce.2004. “The Logic of Sanctioning Welfare Recipients: An Empirical Assessment.” Social Service Review 78: 304–19. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Kalil, Ariel, Seefeldt, Kristin S., Wang, Hui-chen.2002. “Sanctions and Material Hardship under TANF.” Social Service Review 76: 643–62. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Keech, William R. [1968]1981. The Impact of Negro Voting: The Role of the Vote in the Quest for Equality. Chicago, IL and Westport, CT: Rand McNally and Greenwood. Google Scholar | |
| Keiser, Lael R., Meuser, Peter, Choi, Seung-Whan.2004. “Race, Bureaucratic Discretion, and the Implementation of Welfare Reform.” American Journal of Political Science 48: 314–27. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Key, V. O. 1949. Southern Politics in State and Nation. New York: Knopf. Google Scholar | |
| Kinder, Donald R., Palfrey, Thomas, eds.1993. Experimental Foundations of Political Science. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Koralek, Robin.2000. “South Carolina Family Independence Program Process Evaluation.” Prepared for South Carolina Department of Social Services. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute. Google Scholar | |
| Lieberman, Robert C. 1998. Shifting the Color Line: Race and the American Welfare State. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Google Scholar | |
| Lindhorst, Taryn, Mancoske, Ronald J., Kemp, Alice A..2000. “Is Welfare Reform Working? A Study of the Effects of Sanctions on Families Receiving TANF.” Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare 27 (4): 185–201. Google Scholar | |
| Lipsky, Michael.1980. Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. New York: Russell Sage. Google Scholar | |
| Loprest, Pamela J. 2002. Making the Transition from Welfare to Work: Successes by Continuing Concerns Pp. 17–31 in Welfare Reform: The Next Act, edited by Weil, A., Finegold, K.. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press. Google Scholar | |
| Mancuso, David, Lindler, Vanessa L..2001. “Examining the Circumstances of Welfare Leavers and Sanctioned Families in Sonoma County Final Report.” SPHERE Institute, Burlingame, CA. Google Scholar | |
| Maynard-Moody, Steven, Musheno, Michael.2003. Cops, Teachers, Counselors: Stories from the Front Lines of Public Service. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Mead, Lawrence M., ed.1997. The New Paternalism: Supervisory Approaches to Poverty. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press. Google Scholar | |
| Munnell, Alicia H., Tootell, Geoffrey M. B., Browne, Lynn E., McEneaney, James.1996. “Mortgage Lending in Boston: Interpreting HMDA Data.” American Economic Association 86: 25–53. Google Scholar | |
| Neubeck, Kenneth, Cazenave, Noel.2001. Welfare Racism: Playing the Race Card Against America's Poor. New York: Routledge. Google Scholar | |
| Pager, Devah.2007. Marked: Race, Crime, and Finding Work in an Era of Mass Incarceration. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Pavetti, LaDonna A., Derr, Michelle K., Hesketh, Heather.2003. “Review of Sanction Policies and Research Studies: Final Literature Review.” Report prepared for ASPE. Washington, DC: Mathematica Policy Research. Google Scholar | |
| Pavetti, LaDonna A., Derr, Michelle K., Kirby, Gretchen, Wood, Robert G., Clark, Melissa A..2004. “The Use of TANF Work-Oriented Sanctions in Illinois, New Jersey, and South Carolina: Final Report.” Report prepared for ASPE. Washington, DC: Mathematica Policy Research. Google Scholar | |
| Quadagno, Jill.1994. The Color of Welfare: How Racism Undermined the War on Poverty. New York: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar | |
| Quillian, Lincoln.2008. “Does Unconscious Racism Exist.” Social Psychology Quarterly 71 (1): 6–11. Google Scholar, SAGE Journals, ISI | |
| Rector, Robert E., Youssef, Sarah E..1999. “The Determinants of Welfare Caseload Decline.” Report no. 99-04. Washington, DC: Heritage Foundation. Google Scholar | |
| Reese, Ellen.2005. Backlash against Welfare Mothers: Then and Now. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Google Scholar | |
| Reichman, Nancy E., Teitler, Julian O., Curtis, Marah A..2005. “TANF Sanctioning and Hardship.” Social Service Review 79 (2): 215–36. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Richards, Zoe, Hewstone, Miles.2001. “Subtyping and Subgrouping: Processes for the Prevention and Promotion of Stereotype Change.” Personality and Social Psychology Review 5: 52–73. Google Scholar, SAGE Journals, ISI | |
| Schneider, Anne, Ingram, Helen.1997. “The Social Construction of Target Populations: Implications for Politics and Policy.” American Political Science Review 87: 334–47. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Schram, Sanford F. 2005. “Contextualizing Racial Disparities in American Welfare Reform: Toward a New Poverty Research.” Perspectives on Politics 3: 253–68. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Schram, Sanford F. 2006. Welfare Discipline: Discourse, Governance, and Globalization. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press. Google Scholar | |
| Schram, Sanford F., Fording, Richard C., Soss, Joe.2008. “Neoliberal Poverty Governance: Race, Place and the Punitive Turn in U.S. Welfare Policy.” Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 1: 1–20. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Schram, Sanford F., Soss, Joe, Fording, Richard C..2003. Race and the Politics of Welfare Reform. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Schulman, K. A., Berlin, Jesse A., Harless, William, Kerner, Jon F., Sistrunk, Shyrl, Gersh, Bernard J., Dubee, Ross, Taleghani, Christopher K., Burke, Jennifer E., Williams, Sankey, Eisenberg, John M., Escarce, Josee J., Ayers, William.1999. “The Effect of Race and Sex on Physicians' Recommendations for Cardiac Catheterization.” New England Journal of Medicine 340: 618–26. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI | |
| Shaw, Kathleen M., Goldrick-Rab, Sara, Mazzeo, Christopher, Jacobs, Jerry A..2006. Putting Poor People to Work: How the Work-First Idea Eroded College Access for the Poor. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Google Scholar | |
| Soss, Joe, Fording, Richard C., Schram, Sanford F..2008. “The Color of Devolution: The Politics of Local Punishment in an Era of Neo-liberal Welfare Reform.” American Journal of Political Science 52: 536–53. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Soss, Joe, Schram, Sanford F., Vartanian, Thomas, O'Brien, Erin.2001. “Setting the Terms of Relief: Explaining State Policy Choices in the Devolution Revolution.” American Journal of Political Science 45: 378–95. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Stahl, Roland.2008. “Examining TANF Sanction Policies: Who Gets Sanctioned and What Are the Effects?” Phd Dissertation, Graduate School of Social Work and Social Research, Bryn Mawr College, Bryn Mawr, PA. Google Scholar | |
| Starobin, Paul.1998. “The Daddy State.” National Journal 28 (March): 678–83. Google Scholar | |
| Valentino, Nicholas A., Hutchings, Vincent, White, Ismail K..2002. “Cues that Matter: How Political Ads Prime Racial Attitudes During Campaigns.” American Political Science Review 96: 75–90. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Wacquant, Loic.2001. “The Penalisation of Poverty and the Rise of Neo-Liberalism.” European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 9: 401–11. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Watkins-Hayes, Celeste.2009. The New Welfare Bureaucrats: Situated Bureaucrats and Entanglements of Race, Class, and Welfare. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar, Crossref | |
| Weissert, Carol S., ed.2000. Learning from Leaders: Welfare Reform Politics and Policy in Five Midwestern States. Albany, NY: Rockefeller Institute Press. Google Scholar | |
| Western, Bruce.2006. Punishment and Inequality in America. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Google Scholar | |
| Wissoker, Douglas, Zimmermann, Wendy, Galster, George, eds.1998. Testing for Discrimination in Home Insurance. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press. Google Scholar | |
| Wu, Chi-Fang, Cancian, Maria, Meyer, Daniel R., Wallace, Geoffrey.2006. “How Do Welfare Sanctions Work?” Social Work Research 30: 33–51. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI | |
| Yinger, John.1995. Closed Doors, Opportunities Lost: The Continuing Costs of Housing Discrimination. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Google Scholar |
