Abstract
Controversies over string theory (collectively termed the ‘string wars’) intensified in 2005. Also in that year, the open-access preprint publisher arXiv instituted a new feature called a ‘trackback’. This new feature enabled authors of blog posts discussing a paper on arXiv to leave a trackback (a link) to the post on the paper’s abstract page on arXiv. The determination of which specific bloggers would have access to the feature generated a public controversy that was played out in the blogosphere. Although the community was in almost unanimous agreement that so-called ‘crackpots’ should not have access to the trackback feature, it was unable to reach a consensus as to how to define a ‘crackpot’ or an ‘active researcher’. Blogs may provide a window into science in the making, yet this study shows that blogs confound categorization as permanent or ephemeral scholarly communication. The trackback feature was originally conceived to develop certain blog discourse as an alternative or complementary form of peer review. However, the high-energy physics community as a whole questions the ongoing function of the blog.
References
Section:
| Ade PAR, Aikin RW, Barkats D, . (2014a) BICEP2 I: Detection of B-mode polarization at degree angular scales. ArXiv preprint. Available at: http://arxiv.org/abs/1403.3985 Google Scholar | |
| Ade PAR, Aikin RW, Barkats D, . (2014b) Detection of B-mode polarization at degree angular scales by BICEP2. Physical Review Letters 112(24): 241101. Google Scholar Medline | |
| Baez J (1993–2011) This week’s finds. Available at: http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/TWF.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Baez J (1998) The crackpot index. Available at: http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/crackpot.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Batts SA, Anthis NJ, Smith TC (2008) Advancing science through conversations: Bridging the gap between blogs and the academy. PLoS Biology 6: e240. Google Scholar Medline | |
| Bonetta L (2007) Scientists enter the blogosphere. Cell 129(3): 443–445. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2007.04.032 Google Scholar | |
| Capitalist Imperialist Pig (2004–2016) Capitalist imperialist pig. Available at: http://capitalistimperialistpig.blogspot.co.uk/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Capitalist Imperialist Pig (2006) Isn’t it ironic. Capitalist Imperialist Pig, 7 March. Available at: http://capitalistimperialistpig.blogspot.co.uk/2006/03/isnt-it-ironic_07.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Carroll S (2005a) Arxiv.org joins the blogosphere. Cosmic Variance, 24 August. Available at: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2005/08/24/arxivorg-joins-the-blogosphere/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Carroll S (2005b) Two cheers for string theory. Cosmic Variance, 21 July. Available at: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2005/07/21/two-cheers-for-string-theory/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Carroll S (2006a) Crackpots, contrarians and the free market of ideas. Cosmic Variance, 3 March. Available at: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2006/03/03/crackpots-contrarians-and-the-free-market-of-ideas/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Carroll S (2006b) String theory backlash. Cosmic Variance, 19 June. Available at: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2006/06/19/the-string-theory-backlash/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Carroll S (2006c) Welcome to the blogosphere. APS News, May. Available at: http://www.aps.org/publications/apsnews/200605/backpage.cfm (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Carroll S (2012–2016) Preposterous universe. Available at: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Collins H (2014) Rejecting knowledge claims inside and outside science. Social Studies of Science 44(5): 722–735. Google Scholar Abstract | |
| Dawid R (2007) Scientific realism in the age of string theory. Physics & Philosophy 11: 1–35. Google Scholar | |
| Dawid R (2009) On the conflicting assessments of the current status of string theory. Philosophy of Science 76(5): 984–996. Google Scholar | |
| Distler J (2002–2016) Musings. Available at: https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/~distler/blog/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Distler J (2002) With enough eyeballs: A manifesto. Musings, 27 October. Available at: https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/~distler/blog/archives/000018.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Distler J (2005) Trackbacks and the arXivs. Musings, 24 August. Available at: https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/~distler/blog/archives/000638.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Distler J (2006) ArXiv trackback policy. Musings, 5 March. Available at: https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/~distler/blog/archives/000760.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Falkowski A (2014) Is BICEP wrong? Resonances, 12 May. Available at: http://resonaances.blogspot.co.uk/2014/05/is-bicep-wrong.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Galison P (1995) Theory bound and unbound: Superstrings and experiment. In: Weinert F (ed.) Laws of Nature: Essays on the Philosophical, Scientific and Historical Dimensions. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 369–408. Google Scholar | |
| Garvey WD (1979) Communication: The Essence of Science Facilitating Information Exchange among Librarians, Scientists, Engineers, and Students. New York: Pergamon Press. Google Scholar | |
| Gieryn TF (1983) Boundary-work and the demarcation of science from non-science: Strains and interests in professional ideologies of scientists. American Sociological Review 48(6): 781–795. Google Scholar CrossRef | |
| Gieryn TF (1999) Cultural Boundaries of Science: Credibility on the Line. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar | |
| Ginsparg P (1994) First steps toward electronic research communication. Computers in Physics 8(4): 390–396. Google Scholar | |
| Ginsparg P (2011) It was twenty years ago today. ArXiv. Available at: http://arxiv.org/abs/1108.2700 Google Scholar | |
| Griffiths M (2007) Talking physics in the social web. Physics World 20(1): 24–28. Google Scholar | |
| Grossman L (2014) Rumours swirl over credibility of big bang ripple find. New Scientist, 13 May. Available at: https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn25558-rumours-swirl-over-credibility-of-big-bang-ripple-find/ Google Scholar | |
| Gunnarsdóttir K (2005) Scientific journal publications on the role of electronic preprint exchange in the distribution of scientific literature. Social Studies of Science 35(4): 549–579. Google Scholar Abstract | |
| Hippel GV (2006) ArXiv trackback controversy. Life on the Lattice, 27 February. Available at: http://latticeqcd.blogspot.com.au/2006/02/arxiv-trackback-controversy.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| inSPIRE (2014) inSPIRE. Available at: https://inspirehep.net/?ln=en (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Kling R (2004) The internet and unrefereed scholarly publishing. Annual Review of Information Science and Technology 38(1): 591–631. Google Scholar | |
| Kouper I (2010) Science blogs and public engagement with science: Practices, challenges, and opportunities. Journal of Science Communication 9(1): 1–10. Google Scholar | |
| Kragh H (2011) Higher Speculations: Grand Theories and Failed Revolutions in Physics and Cosmology. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar | |
| Luzón MJ (2009) Scholarly hyperwriting: The function of links in academic weblogs. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 60(1): 75–89. Google Scholar | |
| Maron NL, Smith KK (2008) Current Models of Digital Scholarly Communication. Washington, DC: Association of Research Libraries. Google Scholar | |
| Mermin ND (1992) What’s wrong in computopia? Physics Today 45(4): 9. Google Scholar | |
| Meyer ET, Schroeder R (2009) Untangling the web of e-research: Towards a sociology of online knowledge. Journal of Informetrics 3(3): 246–260. Google Scholar | |
| Minol K, Spelsberg G, Schulte E and Morris N (2007) Portals, blogs and co.: The role of the Internet as a medium of science communication. Biotechnology Journal 2(9): 1129–1140. Google Scholar Medline | |
| Motl L (2004–2016) The reference frame. Available at: http://motls.blogspot.co.uk/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Motl L (2006) Crackpots and scientific resources. The Reference Frame, 4 March. Available at: http://motls.blogspot.in/2006/03/crackpots-and-scientific-resources.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Motl L (2007) Science: Climate uncertainties cannot go away. The Reference Frame, 26 October. Available at: http://motls.blogspot.co.uk/2007/10/science-climate-uncertainties-cannot-go.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Orzel C (2006) Physics catfight. Uncertain Principles, 6 March. Available at: http://scienceblogs.com/principles/2006/03/06/physics-catfight/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Pikas CK (2008) Detecting communities in science blogs. In: IEEE Fourth International Conference on eScience, 2008 (eScience’08), Indianapolis, IN, 7–12 December, 95–102. New York: IEEE. Google Scholar | |
| Puschmann C, Mahrt M (2012) Scholarly blogging: A new form of publishing or science journalism 2.0? In: Tokar A, Beurskens M, Keuneke S, (eds) Science and the Internet. Düsseldorf: Düsseldorf University, 171–181. Google Scholar | |
| Rickles D (2014) A Brief History of String Theory: From Dual Models to M-Theory. Berlin: Springer. Google Scholar | |
| Riesch H, Mendel J (2014) Science blogging: Networks, boundaries and limitations. Science as Culture 23(1): 51–72. Google Scholar | |
| Ritson S, Camilleri K (2015) Contested boundaries: The string theory debates and ideologies of science. Perspectives on Science 23(2): 192–227. Google Scholar | |
| Schmidt G (2008) To blog or not to blog? Nature Geoscience 1(4): 208. Google Scholar | |
| Shema H, Bar-Ilan J, Thelwall M (2012) Research blogs and the discussion of scholarly information. PLoS ONE 7(5): e35869. Google Scholar CrossRef, Medline | |
| Shema H, Bar-Ilan J, Thelwall M (2014) Do blog citations correlate with a higher number of future citations? Research blogs as a potential source for alternative metrics. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology 65(5): 1018–1027. Google Scholar | |
| Shuai X, Pepe A, Bollen J (2012) How the scientific community reacts to newly submitted preprints: Article downloads, twitter mentions, and citations. PLoS ONE 7(11): e47523. Google Scholar Medline | |
| Siegel W (n.d.) Are you a quack? Available at: http://insti.physics.sunysb.edu/~siegel/quack.html Google Scholar | |
| Smith D (2008) A parallel universe? Blogs, wikis, Web 2.0 and a complicated future for scholarly communication. Serials: The Journal for the Serials Community 21(1): 14–18. Google Scholar | |
| Smolin L (2006) The Trouble with Physics: The Rise of String Theory, the Fall of a Science, and What Comes Next. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin. Google Scholar | |
| Taubes G (1993) Publication by electronic mail takes physics by storm. Science 259(5099): 1246–1248. Google Scholar Medline | |
| ‘t Hooft G (n.d.) How to become a bad theoretical physicist. Available at: http://www.staff.science.uu.nl/~hooft101/theoristbad.html (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Trench B (2008) Internet: Turning science communication inside-out? In: Bucchi M, Trench B (eds) Handbook of Public Communication of Science and Technology. London: Routledge, 185–199. Google Scholar | |
| Trench B (2012) Scientists’ blogs: Glimpses behind the scenes. In: Rödder S, Franzen M, Weingart P (eds) The Sciences’ Media Connection – Public Communication and Its Repercussions. Dordrecht: Springer, 273–289. Google Scholar CrossRef | |
| Various (2003–2006) The string coffee table. Available at: https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/string/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Various (2005–2013) Cosmic variance. Available at: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Warden R (2010) The Internet and science communication: Blurring the boundaries. Ecancermedicalscience 4: 203. Google Scholar Medline | |
| Wilkins JS (2008) The roles, reasons and restrictions of science blogs. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 23(8): 411–413. Google Scholar Medline | |
| Woit P (2004–2016) Not even wrong. Available at: http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/ (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar | |
| Woit P (2006) Letter to the arXiv advisory board. Not Even Wrong, 23 February. Available at: http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=353 (accessed 13 December 2014). Google Scholar |
