![[PDF]](/pb-assets/Icons/adobe-pdf-icon-1498649896243.png){kind=icon}
Abstract
About one third of patients with epilepsy do not benefit from medical treatment. For these patients electroencephalographic (EEG) biofeedback is a viable alternative. EEG biofeedback, or neurofeedback, normalizes or enhances EEG activity by means of operant conditioning. While dozens of scientific reports have been published on neurofeedback for seizure disorder, most have been case series with too few subjects to establish efficacy. The purpose of this paper is to meta-analyze existing research on neurofeedback and epilepsy.
We analyzed every EEG biofeedback study indexed in MedLine, PsychInfo, and PsychLit databases between 1970 and 2005 on epilepsy that provided seizure frequency change in response to feedback. Sixty-three studies have been published, 10 of which provided enough outcome information to be included in a meta-analysis. All studies consisted of patients whose seizures were not controlled by medical therapies, which is a very important factor to keep in mind when interpreting the results. Nine of 10 studies reinforced sensorimotor rhythms (SMR) while 1 study trained slow cortical potentials (SCP). All studies reported an overall mean decreased seizure incidence following treatment and 64 out of 87 patients (74%) reported fewer weekly seizures in response to EEG biofeedback. Treatment effect was mean log (post/pre) where pre and post represent number of seizures per week prior to treatment and at final evaluation, respectively. Due to prevalence of small groups, Hedges's g was computed for effect size. As sample heterogeneity was possible (Q test, p=.18), random effects were assumed and the effect of intervention was −0.233, SE= 0.057, z 
−4.11, p<.001.
Based on this meta-analysis, EEG operant conditioning was found to produce a significant reduction on seizure frequency. This finding is especially noteworthy given the patient group, individuals who had been unable to control their seizures with medical treatment.
Keywords EEG Biofeedback, Epilepsy, Meta-Analysis, Neurofeedback, Neurotherapy, Seizure
References
Section:
| 1. | World Health Organization (2001) . Epilepsy: etiology, epidemiology and prognosis, http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs165/en/index.html. Retrieved August 20, 2008. Google Scholar |
| 2. | Witte, H, Iasemidis, ID, Litt, B. Special issue on epileptic seizure prediction. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 2003; 50: 537–539,. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI |
| 3. | Iasemidis, ID . Epileptic seizure prediction and control. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 2003; 50: 549–558. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 4. | Wyrwicka, W, Sterman, MB. Instrumental conditioning of sensorimotor cortex EEG spindles in the waking cat. Physiol Behav 1968; 3: 703–707. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI |
| 5. | Sterman, MB, Wyrwicka, W, Roth, SR. Electrophysiological correlates and neural substrates of alimentary behaviour in the cat. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1969; 157: 723–739. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 6. | Sterman, MB, Goodman, SJ, Kovalesky, RA. Effects of sensorimotor EEG feedback training on seizure susceptibility in the rhesus monkey. Exp Neurol 1978; 62: 735–747. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 7. | Sterman, MB, Friar, L. Suppression of seizures in an epileptic following sensorimotor EEG feedback training. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1972; 33: 89–95. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 8. | Sterman, MB . Basic concepts and clinical findings in the treatment of seizure disorders with EEG operant conditioning. Clin Electroencephalogr 2000; 31: 45–55. Google Scholar, SAGE Journals |
| 9. | Lubar, JF, Shabsin, HS, Natelson, SE, Holder, GS, Whitsett, SF, Pamplin, WE, Krulikowski, DI. EEG operant conditioning in intractable epileptics. Arch Neurol 1981; 38: 11, 700–704. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 10. | Sterman, MB, Macdonald, LR, Stone, RK. Biofeedback training of the sensorimotor electroencephalogram rhythm in man: effects on epilepsy. Epilepsia 1974; 15: 395–416. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 11. | Cott, A, Pavloski, RP, Black, AH. Reducing epileptic seizures through operant conditioning of central nervous system activity; procedural variables. Science, New Series 1979; 203: 73–75. Google Scholar |
| 12. | Hansen, LM, Trudeau, DL, Grace, DL. Neurotherapy and drug therapy in combination for adult ADHD, personality disorder, and seizure disorder: a case report. J Neurotherapy 1996; 2: 6–14. Google Scholar, Crossref |
| 13. | Lantz, D, Sterman, MB. Neuropsychological assessment of subjects with uncontrolled epilepsy: effects of EEG feedback training. Epilepsia 1988; 29: 163–171. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 14. | Tozzo, CA, Elfner, LF, May, JG. EEG biofeedback and relaxation training in the control of epileptic seizures. Int J Psychophysiol 1988; 3: 185–194. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI |
| 15. | Ikeda, A, Terada, K, Mikuni, N, Burgess, RC, Comari, Y, Taki, W. Subdural recording of ictal DC shifts in neocortical seizures in humans. Epilepsia 1996; 37: 662–674. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 16. | Egner, T, Sterman, MB. Neurofeedback treatment of epilepsy: from basic rationale to practical application. Expert Rev Neurotherapeutics 2006; 6: 247–257. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 17. | Walker, JE, Kozlowski, GP. Neurofeedback treatment of epilepsy. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am 2005; 14: 163–176. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 18. | La Vaque, T, Hammond, DC, Trudeau, D, Monastra, V, Perry, J, Lehrer, PL. Template for developing guidelines for the evaluation of the clinical efficacy of psycho-physiological interventions. Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback 2002; 27: 273–281. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 19. | Andrews, DJ, Schonfeld, WH. Predictive factors for controlling seizures using a behavioral approach. Seizure 1992; 1: 111–116. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 20. | Sterman, MB, Shouse, MN. Quantitative analysis of training, sleep EEG and clinical response to EEG operant conditioning in epileptics. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1980; 49: 558–576. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 21. | Sterman, MB EEG biofeedback in the treatment of epilepsy: an overview circa 1980. In: White, L, Tursky, B, (eds). Clinical Biofeedback: Efficacy and Mechanisms. New York: Guilford Press; 1982: 311–330. Google Scholar |
| 22. | Whitsett, SF, Lubar, JF, Holder, GS, Natelson, S. A double-blind investigation of the relationship between seizure activity and the sleep EEG following EEG biofeedback training. Biofeedback Self-Regul 1982; 7: 193–209. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 23. | Kotchoubey, B, Strehl, U, Uhlmann, C, Holzapfel, S, Konig, M, Froescher, W. Modification of slow cortical potentials in patients with refractory epilepsy: a controlled outcome study. Epilepsia 2001; 42: 406–416. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 24. | Rockstroh, B, Elbert, T, Birbaumer, N, Wolf, P, Duechting-Roth, A, Reker, M. Cortical self-regulation in patients with epilepsies. Epilepsy Res 1993; 14: 63–72. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 25. | Holzapfel, S, Strehl, U, Kotchoubey, B, Birbaumer, N. Behavioral psychophysiological intervention in a mentally retarded epileptic patient with brain lesions. Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback 1998; 23: 189–202. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 26. | Kuhlman, WN, Allison, T. EEG feedback training in the treatment of epilepsy: some questions and some answers. Pavlov J Biol Sci 1977; 12: 112–122. Google Scholar, Medline |
| 27. | Kleijnen, J, de Craen, AJ, van Everdingen, J, Krol, L. Placebo effect in doubleblind clinical trials: a review of interactions with medications. Lancet 1994; 344: 1347–1349. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 28. | Petty, SJ, O'Brien, TJ, Wark, JD. Anti-epileptic medication and bone health. Osteoporos Int 2007; 18: 129–142. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 29. | Bohan, KH, Mansuri, TF, Wilson, NM. Anticonvulsant hypersensitivity syndrome: implications for pharmaceutical care. Pharmacotherapy 2007; 27: 1425–1439. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 30. | Rasalam, AD, Hailey, H, Williams, JH, Moore, SJ, Turnpenny, PD, Lloyd, DJ, Dean, JC. Characteristics of fetal anticonvulsant syndrome associated autistic disorder. Dev Med Child Neurol 2005; 47: 551–555. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 31. | Pennell, PB . Pregnancy in the woman with epilepsy: maternal and fetal outcomes. Semin Neurol 2002; 22: 299–308. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 32. | Finley, WW . Operant conditioning of the EEG in two patients with epilepsy: methodologic and clinical considerations. Pavlov J Biol Sci 1977; 12: 93–111. Google Scholar, Medline |
| 33. | Tansey, MA . The response of a case of petit mal epilepsy to EEG sensorimotor rhythm biofeedback training. Int J Psychophysiol 1985; 3: 81–84. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 34. | Johnson, RK, Meyer, RG. Phased biofeedback approach for epileptic seizure control. J Behav Therapy Experim Psychiatry 1974; 5: 185–187. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI |
| 35. | Zhao, L, Wu, W, Liang, Z, Hu, G. Nonlinear analysis in treatment of intractable epilepsy with EEG biofeedback. Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol 2005; 5: 4568–4571. Google Scholar, Medline |
| 36. | Wyler, AR, Lockard, JS, Ward, AA. Conditioned EEG desynchronization and seizure occurrence in patients. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1976; 41: 501–512. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 37. | Quy, RJ, Hutt, SJ, Forrest, S. Sensorimotor rhythm feedback training and epilepsy: some methodological and conceptual issues. Biol Psychiatry 1979; 9: 129–149. Google Scholar, Crossref, ISI |
| 38. | Lubar, JF, Bahler, WW. Behavioral management of epileptic seizures following EEG biofeedback training of the sensorimotor rhythm. Biofeedback Self-Regul 1976; 1: 77–104. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 39. | Sterman, MB, Macdonald, LR. Effects of central cortical EEG feedback training on incidence of poorly controlled seizures. Epilepsia. 1978; 19: 207–222. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
| 40. | Kaplan, BJ . Biofeedback in epileptics: Equivocal relationship of reinforced EEG frequency to seizure reduction. Epilepsia 1975; 16: 477–485. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline, ISI |
