There is a national movement to universalize the high school curriculum so that all students graduate prepared for college. The present work evaluates a policy in Chicago that ended remedial classes and mandated college preparatory course work for all students. Based on an interrupted time-series cohort design with multiple comparisons, this study found that the policy reduced inequities in ninth grade course work by entering ability, race/ethnicity, and special education status. Although more students completed ninth grade with credits in algebra and English I, failure rates increased, grades slightly declined, test scores did not improve, and students were no more likely to enter college. In sum, few benefits resulted from universalizing college preparatory course work among freshmen, but dropout rates did not increase. Possible explanations are discussed.

AchieveClosing the expectations gap 2007: An annual 50-state progress report on the alignment of high school policies with the demands of college and work2007Retrieved February 15, 2008, from http://www.achieve.org/node/844 , Google Scholar
ACTCrisis at the core: Preparing all students for college and work2004Iowa City, IAAuthor , Google Scholar
ACTBenefits of a high school core curriculum for students in urban high schools.2007Retrieved February 15, 2008, from http://www.act.org/research/policymakers/pdf/core_curriculum.pdf , Google Scholar
AdelmanCThe new college course map and transcript files: Changes in course-taking and achievement, 1972–19931995Washington, DCNational Institute on Postsecondary Education, Libraries, and Lifelong Learning(No. PE-95-8001). , Google Scholar
AllensworthEEastonJQWhat matters for staying on-track and graduating in Chicago public high schools: A close look at course grades, failures and attendance in the freshman year2007ChicagoConsortium on Chicago School Research , Google Scholar
American Diploma ProjectReady or not: Creating a high school diploma that counts2004Washington, DCAchieve , Google Scholar
AngusDMirelJThe failed promise of the American high school, 1890–19951999New YorkTeachers College Press , Google Scholar
ArgysLMReesDIBrewerDJDetracking America’s schools: Equity at zero cost?Journal of Policy Analysis and Management1996154623645 , Google Scholar
AttewellPDominaTRaising the bar: Curricular intensity and academic performanceEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis2008305171 , Google Scholar Abstract
BarrRDreebenRHow schools work1983ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press , Google Scholar
BoalerJSetting, social class, and survival of the quickestBritish Educational Research Journal1997235575595 , Google Scholar
BoalerJStaplesMCreating mathematical futures through an equitable teaching approach: The case of Railside SchoolTeachers College Record20081103608645 , Google Scholar
BrykASLeeVEHollandPBCatholic schools and the common good1993Cambridge, MAHarvard University Press , Google Scholar
ChaneyBBurgdorfKAtashNInfluencing achievement through high school graduation requirementsEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis199719229244 , Google Scholar Abstract
CluneWHWhitePAEducation reform in the trenches: Increased academic course taking in high schools with lower achieving students in states with higher graduation requirementsEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis199214220 , Google Scholar Abstract
CreminLAThe transformation of the school: Progressivism in American education1961New YorkKnopf , Google Scholar
DebrayEA comprehensive high school and a shift in New York State policy: A study of early implementationThe High School Journal20058911845 , Google Scholar
GamoranAHanniganECAlgebra for everyone? Benefits of college-preparatory mathematics for students with diverse abilities in early secondary schoolEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis200022241254 , Google Scholar Abstract
GamoranAMareRDSecondary school tracking and educational inequality: Compensation, reinforcement, or neutrality?American Journal of Sociology19899411461183 , Google Scholar
GamoranANystrandMBerendsMLePorePCAn organizatinal analysis of the effects of ability groupingAmerican Educational Research Journal1995324687715 , Google Scholar Abstract
GamoranAWeinsteinMDifferentiation and opportunity in restructured schoolsAmerican Journal of Education1998106385415 , Google Scholar
HallinanMTracking: From theory to practiceSociology of Education19946727984 , Google Scholar
HofferTBHigh school graduation requirements: Effects of dropping out and student achievementTeachers College Record199798584607 , Google Scholar
HornLKojakuLKHigh school academic curriculum and the persistence path through college: Persistence and transfer behavior of undergraduates 3 years after entering 4-year institutionsEducation Statistics Quarterly2001336572 , Google Scholar
KliebardHMThe struggle for the American curriculum 1893–19581995New YorkRoutledge , Google Scholar
LeeVERestructuring high schools for equity and excellence: What works2002New YorkTeachers College Press , Google Scholar
LeeVEBrykASCurriculum tracking as mediating the social distribution of high school achievementSociology of Education1988617894 , Google Scholar
LeeVEBrykASA multilevel model of the social distribution of high school achievementSociology of Education198962172192 , Google Scholar
LeeVEBurkamDTChow-HoyTSmerdonBAGeverdtDHigh school curriculum structure: Effects of course-taking and achievement in mathematics for high school graduates An examination of data from the National Education Longitudinal Study of 19881998Washington, DCU.S. Department of Education, Office of Educational Research and Development, National Center for Educational Statistics(Working Paper No 98-09). , Google Scholar
LeeVECroningerRGSmithJBCourse-taking, equity, and mathematics learning: Testing the constrained curriculum hypothesis in U.S. secondary schoolsEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis19971999121 , Google Scholar Abstract
LeeVEReadyDDSchools within schools: Possibilities and pitfalls of high school reform2007New YorkTeachers College Press , Google Scholar
LeeVESmithJBEffects of high school restructuring and size on early gains in achievement and engagementSociology of Education199568241270 , Google Scholar
LeeVESmithJBCroningerRGHow high school organization influences the equitable distribution of learning in mathematics and scienceSociology of Education199770128150 , Google Scholar
LiebermanAEThe work of restructuring schools: Building from the ground up1995New YorkTeachers College Press , Google Scholar
LovelessTThe tracking wars: State reform meets school policy1999Washington, DCBrookings Institution , Google Scholar
LucasSRTracking inequality: Stratification and mobility in American high schools1999New YorkTeachers College Press , Google Scholar
MillerSRAllensworthEMLeeVProgress and problems: Student performance in CPS high schools, 1993 to 2000Reforming Chicago’s high schools: Research perspectives on school and system level change2002ChicagoConsortium on Chicago School Research5187 , Google Scholar
National Commission on Excellence in EducationA nation at risk: The imperative for educational reform1983Washington, DCGovernment Printing Office , Google Scholar
National Governors AssociationGetting it done: Ten steps to a state action agenda2005Retrieved November 8, 2005, from http://www.nga.org/Files/pdf/05warnerguide.pdf , Google Scholar
NewmannFAssociatesAuthentic achievement: Restructuring schools for intellectual quality1996San FranciscoJossey-Bass , Google Scholar
NomiTakakoAllensworthElaine“Double-Dose” Algebra as an Alternative Strategy to Remediation: Effects on Students’ Academic OutcomesJournal of Research on Educational Effectiveness20092111148 , Google Scholar
OakesJKeeping track: How schools structure inequality1985New Haven, CTYale University Press , Google Scholar
OakesJMore than misapplied technology: A normative and political response to Hallinan on trackingSociology of Education19946728491 , Google Scholar
OakesJKeeping track: How schools structure inequality20052nd edNew Haven, CTYale University Press , Google Scholar
OakesJWellsABeyond the technicalities of school reform: Policy lessons from detracking schools1996Los Angeles, CAResearch for Democratic School Communities, University of California, Los Angeles Graduate School of Education and Information Studies , Google Scholar
PowellAGFarrarECohenDKThe shopping mall high school: Winners and losers in the educational marketplace1985BostonHoughton Mifflin , Google Scholar
RosenbaumJEMaking inequality: The hidden curriculum of high school tracking1976New YorkWiley , Google Scholar
RosenbaumJEIf tracking is bad, is detracking betterAmerican Educator1999234244729 , Google Scholar
RubinBCDetracking in context: How local constructions of ability complicate equityTeachers College Record20081103646699 , Google Scholar
SippleJWKilleenKMonkDHAdoption and adaptation: School district responses to state imposed learning and graduation requirementsEducation Evaluation and Policy Analysis200426143168 , Google Scholar Abstract
St. JohnEPMusobaGDGrossJPKChungDGAcademic preparation and college success: Analyses of Indiana’s 2000 high school class2004Indianapolis, INLumina Foundation and Indiana Commission for Higher Education(No. 04-03). , Google Scholar
TeitelbaumPThe influence of high school graduation requirement policies in mathematics and science on student course-taking patterns and achievementEducation Evaulation and Policy Analysis2003253157 , Google Scholar Abstract
WellsASOakesJPotential pitfalls of systemic reform: Early lessons from research on detrackingSociology of Education199669Special issue135143 , Google Scholar
YonezawaSWellsASSernaIChoosing tracks: “Freedom of choice” in detracking schoolsAmerican Educational Research Journal20023913767 , Google Scholar Abstract

Vol 31, Issue 4, 2009

Recommended Citation


College Preparatory Curriculum for All: Academic Consequences of Requiring Algebra and English I for Ninth Graders in Chicago

Elaine AllensworthTakako NomiNicholas MontgomeryUniversity of ChicagoValerie E. LeeUniversity of Michigan


Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis

Vol 31, Issue 4, pp. 367 - 391

First published date: December-01-2009


If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click on download.

For more information or tips please see 'Downloading to a citation manager' in the Help menu.

Format

Download article citation data for:
Elaine AllensworthTakako NomiNicholas MontgomeryValerie E. Lee
Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 2009 31:4, 367-391

Request Permissions

View permissions information for this article

Share

Email