Grasping Visual Illusions: No Evidence for a Dissociation Between Perception and Action
Abstract
Neuropsychological studies prompted the theory that the primate visual system might be organized into two parallel pathways, one for conscious perception and one for guiding action. Supporting evidence in healthy subjects seemed to come from a dissociation in visual illusions: In previous studies, the Ebbinghaus (or Titchener) illusion deceived perceptual judgments of size, but only marginally influenced the size estimates used in grasping. Contrary to those results, the findings from the present study show that there is no difference in the sizes of the perceptual and grasp illusions if the perceptual and grasping tasks are appropriately matched. We show that the differences found previously can be accounted for by a hitherto unknown, nonadditive effect in the illusion. We conclude that the illusion does not provide evidence for the existence of two distinct pathways for perception and action in the visual system.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
Aglioti S., DeSouza J.F.X., Goodale M.A. (1995). Size-contrast illusions deceive the eye but not the hand. Current Biology, 5, 679–685.
Brenner E., Smeets J.B.J. (1996). Size illusion influences how we lift but not how we grasp an object. Experimental Brain Research, 111, 473–476.
Bridgeman B., Lewis S., Heit G., Nagle M. (1979). Relation between cognitive and motor-oriented systems of visual position perception. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 5, 692–700.
Coren S., Girgus J.S. (1972). A comparison of five methods of illusion measurement. Behavior Research Methods & Instrumentation, 4, 240–244.
Coren S., Girgus J.S. (1978). Seeing is deceiving: The psychology of visual illusions. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Coren S., Miller J. (1974). Size contrast as a function of figural similarity. Perception & Psychophysics, 16, 355–357.
Daprati E., Gentilucci M. (1997). Grasping an illusion. Neuropsychologia, 35, 1577–1582.
Goodale M.A., Meenan J.P., Bülthoff H.H., Nicolle D.A., Murphy K.J., Carolynn I.R. (1994). Separate neural pathways for the visual analysis of object shape in perception and prehension. Current Biology, 4, 604–610.
Goodale M.A., Milner A.D. (1992). Separate visual pathways for perception and action. Trends in Neurosciences, 15, 97–112.
Goodale M.A., Milner A.D., Jakobson L.S., Carey D.P. (1991). A neurological dissociation between perceiving objects and grasping them. Nature, 349, 154–156.
Goodale M.A., Pélisson D., Prablanc C. (1986). Large adjustments in visually guided reaching do not depend on vision of the hand or perception of target displacement. Nature, 320, 748–750.
Haffenden A.M., Goodale M.A. (1998). The effect of pictorial illusion on prehension and perception. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 10, 122–136.
Hansen R.M., Skavenski A.A. (1985). Accuracy of spatial localization near the time of a saccadic eye movement. Vision Research, 25, 1077–1082.
Jackson S.R., Husain M. (1997). Visual control of hand action. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 8(1), 310–317.
Jeannerod M. (1981). Intersegmental coordination during reaching at natural visual objects. In Long J., Baddeley A. (Eds.), Attention and performance (Vol. 9, pp. 153–168). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Jeannerod M. (1984). The timing of natural prehension movements. Journal of Motor Behavior, 16, 235–254.
Milner A.D., Goodale M.A. (1995). The visual brain in action. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
Oldfield R.C. (1971). The assessment and analysis of handedness: The Edinburgh Inventory. Neuropsychologia, 9, 97–113.
Post R.B., Welch R.B. (1996). Is there dissociation of perceptual and motor responses to figural illusions? Perception, 25, 569–581.
Pressey A.W. (1977). Measuring the Titchener circles and Delboeuf illusions with the method of adjustment. Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, 10, 118–120.
Ungerleider L.G., Mishkin M. (1982). Two cortical visual systems. In Ingle D.J., Goodale M.A., Mansfield R.J.W. (Eds.), Analysis of visual behavior (pp. 549–586). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published: January 2000
Issue published: January 2000
PubMed: 11228838
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Article usage*
Total views and downloads: 1379
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Altmetric
See the impact this article is making through the number of times it’s been read, and the Altmetric Score.
Learn more about the Altmetric Scores
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 343 view articles Opens in new tab
Crossref: 277
- Reduced perception-action dissociation in children with amblyopia
- Pictorial depth cues always influence reaching distance
- Perceptual Phenomena Cannot Be Approached from a Single Perspective
- Neural networks underlying visual illusions: An activation likelihood ...
- Looking at the Ebbinghaus illusion: differences in neurocomputational ...
- Vertical−horizontal illusory effects with gaze restrictions do not cha...
- How prism adaptation reveals the distinct use of size and positions in...
- Virtual Reality for Vision Science
- Spatial distances affect temporal prediction and interception
- Grasping follows Weber's law: How to use response variability as a pro...
- Use of remote data collection methodology to test for an illusory effe...
- Tau and kappa in interception – how perceptual spatiotemporal interrel...
- Serial dependence for oculomotor control depends on early sensory sign...
- Altered Regional Homogeneity in Patients With Congenital Blindness: A ...
- Unilateral resection of both cortical visual pathways in a pediatric p...
- Selective interference of hand posture with grasping capability estima...
- Explicit and implicit depth-cue integration: Evidence of systematic bi...
- A change in perspective: The interaction of saccadic and pursuit eye m...
- The two visual systems hypothesis and contrastive underdetermination
- Implicit biases in visually guided action
- Ebbinghaus visual illusion: no robust influence on novice golf-putting...
- Temporal Availability of Ebbinghaus Illusions on Perceiving and Intera...
- Gaze Direction Changes the Vertical-Horizontal Illusory Effects on Man...
- Physics of Experiential Now: Effort of Atomic Action
- Double dissociation between perception and action in children
- A double dissociation between action and perception in bimanual graspi...
- The effect of the Müller–Lyer configuration on saccadic eye movements ...
- SNARC-like compatibility effects for physical and phenomenal magnitude...
- Attention updates the perceived position of moving objects
- Stretching the skin immediately enhances perceived stiffness and gradu...
- Why some size illusions affect grip aperture
- Asymmetric Effects of the Ebbinghaus Illusion on Depth Judgments
- Cognitive Science
- Words’ Origin of an Affective State, but not Valence, Shape the Reacti...
- Attenuation of size illusion effect in dual-task conditions
- A review of grasping as the movements of digits in space
- Adaptation to Laterally Asymmetrical Visuomotor Delay Has an Effect on...
- The Uznadze illusion reveals similar effects of relative size on perce...
- The Sixth Sense Organs: The Eyes
- Are large portions always bad? Using the Delboeuf illusion on food pac...
- The Size Congruity Effect Vanishes in Grasping: Implications for the P...
- The target as an obstacle: Grasping an object at different heights
- Motion Extrapolation for Eye Movements Predicts Perceived Motion-Induc...
- Can I reach that? Blind reaching as an accurate measure of estimated r...
- The faster you decide, the more accurate localization is possible: Pos...
- Visual illusions modify object size estimates for prospective action j...
- Force feedback delay affects perception of stiffness but not action, a...
- Memory for retinotopic locations is more accurate than memory for spat...
- The Ebbinghaus illusion in contrast-defined and orientation-defined st...
- Is the Ebbinghaus illusion a size contrast illusion?
- Does visuomotor adaptation contribute to illusion-resistant grasping?
- The role of knowledge on perception in Müller-Lyer illusion
- Perception and Action
- Effects of wrist tendon vibration and eye movements on manual aiming
- Dynamic representations of visual space for perception and action
- Dissociable effects of stimulus range on perception and action
- Errors in interception can be predicted from errors in perception
- Do we have distinct systems for immediate and delayed actions? A selec...
- The Sander parallelogram illusion dissociates action and perception de...
- Memory-guided saccades show effect of a perceptual illusion whereas vi...
- Ebbinghaus figures that deceive the eye do not necessarily deceive the...
- People Are Unable to Recognize or Report on Their Own Eye Movements
- When perception trips action! The increase in the perceived size of bo...
- Interaction of Perception and Action in Discrete and Continuous Rapid ...
- The Perception‐Action Model: Counting Computational Mechanisms
- Spatial Alignment and Response Hand in Geometric and Motion Illusions
- Adaptation effects in grasping the Müller-Lyer illusion
- Real and illusory issues in the illusion debate (Why two things are so...
- Do visual illusions affect grasping? Considerable progress in a scient...
- Processing of probabilistic information in weight perception and motor...
- Handlungssteuerung
- Attention in action and perception: Unitary or separate mechanisms of ...
- Perceptual Averaging in Individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder
- Cognition incarnée : un point de vue sur les représentations spatiales
- Visual motion serves but is not under the purview of the dorsal pathwa...
- Rapid decrement in the effects of the Ponzo display dissociates action...
- Does sensitivity in binary choice tasks depend on response modality?
- The functional subdivision of the visual brain: Is there a real illusi...
- Combined visual illusion effects on the perceived index of difficulty ...
- Visual Consciousness
- Interactions between dorsal and ventral streams for controlling skille...
- Quantifying the Ebbinghaus figure effect: target size, context size, a...
- Visual Neuroscience: Dissociating Perceptual and Occulomotor Localizat...
- Weighing the evidence for a dorsal processing bias under continuous fl...
- Rapid eye movements to a virtual target are biased by illusory context...
- Garner-Interference in left-handed awkward grasping
- The effect of force feedback delay on stiffness perception and grip fo...
- Semantic grasping escapes Weber's law
- Trompe l’oeil and the Dorsal/Ventral Account of Picture Perception
- Future challenges for vection research: definitions, functional signif...
- When Misrepresentation is Successful
- Visual illusions and direct perception: Elaborating on Gibson's insigh...
- Goal-oriented gaze strategies afforded by object interaction
- Monkey see, Monkey reach: Action selection of reaching movements in th...
- Effect of visual and haptic feedback on grasping movements
- The influence of target object shape on maximum grip aperture in human...
- Line-bisectioning and obstacle avoidance: Evidence for separate strate...
- Statistical extraction affects visually guided action
- Superadditivity of the Ebbinghaus and Müller-Lyer Illusions Depends on...
- Unconscious vision and executive control: How unconscious processing a...
- How (and why) the visual control of action differs from visual percept...
- A Common Representation of Spatial Features Drives Action and Percepti...
- Failure to see money on a tree: inattentional blindness for objects th...
- Lack of motor prediction, rather than perceptual conflict, evokes an o...
- Does the Size-Illusion Effect on Prehensile Movements Depend on Previe...
- Ebbinghaus illusion in the tactile modality
- Naturalizing Action Theory
- Using scissors to bisect a line: A perception–action dissociation in c...
- Perceptuomotor rules as prediction tools in (joint) action: The case o...
- Learning to detect but not to grasp suppressed visual stimuli
- The Hand Sees Visual Periphery Better Than the Eye: Motor-Dependent Vi...
- The influence of target context and early and late vision on goal-dire...
- Connecting the Dots...
- Success semantics: the sequel
- Fooling the Eyes: The Influence of a Sound-Induced Visual Motion Illus...
- Schema-Driven Influences in Recovering 3-D Shape from Motion in Human ...
- Does bimanual grasping of the Müller-Lyer illusion provide evidence fo...
- Sind motorische Handlungen auf eine präzise Wahrnehmung angewiesen?
- Motor Control
- Relative size of numerical magnitude induces a size-contrast effect on...
- Functional dissociation between perception and action is evident early...
- Plate Size and Color Suggestibility: The Delboeuf Illusion’s Bias on S...
- Object processing in visual perception and action in children and adul...
- Visual processing for action resists similarity of relevant and irrele...
- Assimilation and contrast: the two sides of specific interference betw...
- Efficient models for grasp planning with a multi-fingered hand
- Commonsense psychology, dual visual streams, and the individuation of ...
- Getting a grip on illusions: replicating Stöttinger et al [Exp Brain R...
- Sex & vision I: Spatio-temporal resolution
- Differential effects of a visual illusion on online visual guidance in...
- No transfer of calibration between action and perception in learning a...
- Visual information and rubber hand embodiment differentially affect re...
- Neural markers of automatic and controlled attention during immediate ...
- Conscious Vision for Action Versus Unconscious Vision for Action?
- Transforming vision into action
- The relationship between allocentric and egocentric frames of referenc...
- Viewing and feeling touch modulates hand position for reaching
- Converging evidence for diverging pathways: Neuropsychology and psycho...
- Vision-for-perception and vision-for-action: Which model is compatible...
- How do illusions constrain goal-directed movement: perceptual and visu...
- Improved change detection with nearby hands
- Saccadic eye movements and perceptual judgments reveal a shared visual...
- A metanalysis of the effect of the Müller-Lyer illusion on saccadic ey...
- What Is an Output?
- Enhancing Implicit Change Detection through Action
- Grasping for parsimony: Do some motor actions escape dorsal processing...
- The Ebbinghaus illusion deceives adults but not young children
- The effect of the Müller-Lyer illusion on saccades is modulated by spa...
- Division of labour within the visual system: fact or fiction? Which ki...
- Is simple reaction time affected by visual illusions?
- On interference effects in concurrent perception and action
- Do we have independent visual streams for perception and action?
- Pointing in Stereoscopic Space
- The limits of visual mass perception
- Egocentric Spatial Representation in Action and Perception*
- Saccades reveal that allocentric coding of the moving object causes mi...
- Grasping isoluminant stimuli
- Opposite haptic and visual induction effects observed with Titchener’s...
- Infants’ responsiveness to pictorial depth cues in preferential-reachi...
- Consistency in exchange for inappropriately matched visual feedback? A...
- Comparison of Perceptual and Motor Decisions Via Confidence Judgments ...
- Memory mechanisms in grasping
- Visual illusions, delayed grasping, and memory: No shift from dorsal t...
- When is grasping affected by the Müller-Lyer illusion?
- The involvement of cognitive processing in a perceptual-motor process ...
- Grasping the diagonal: Controlling attention to illusory stimuli for a...
- Does My Step Look Big In This? A Visual Illusion Leads To Safer Steppi...
- Another look at the Müller-Lyer illusion: Different gaze patterns in v...
- Grasping Occam’s Razor
- Visual Consciousness: An Updated Neurological Tour
- The rubber hand illusion in action
- Grasping visual illusions: Consistent data and no dissociation
- Action without perception in human vision
- Grasping Weber's illusion: The effect of receptor density differences ...
- Dissociations in rod bisection: The effect of viewing conditions on pe...
- State-trace analysis of the effects of a visual illusion on saccade am...
- Processing Spatial Layout by Perception and Sensorimotor Interaction
- The specificity of learned associations in visuomotor and perceptual p...
- Visual prediction: Psychophysics and neurophysiology of compensation f...
- Action Rules: Why the Visual Control of Reaching and Grasping is Not A...
- The Scope and Limits of Enactive Approaches to Visual Experience
- Pre-Emptive Perception
- A Double Dissociation Between Action and Perception in the Context of ...
- Attention for perception and action: task interference for action plan...
- Effects of the Ebbinghaus illusion on children’s perception and graspi...
- Depth cues, rather than perceived depth, govern vergence
- Practice makes perfect, but only with the right hand: Sensitivity to p...
- Two visual systems re-viewed
- Voluntary and reflexive eye movements to illusory lengths
- Neurobiologia na tropie świadomości
- Interactions between perception and action programming: Evidence from ...
- When does action resist visual illusion? The effect of Müller–Lyer sti...
- Top-down influences make saccades deviate away: The case of endogenous...
- Unconscious Vision and the Platitudes of Folk Psychology
- Perceived Slant: A Dissociation between Perception and Action
- The processing of linear perspective and binocular information for act...
- Grasping the Müller-Lyer illusion: The contributions of vision for per...
- Do visual illusions probe the visual brain?
- Obstacle avoidance during walking in real and virtual environments
- 2-D Tilt and 3-D Slant Illusions in Perception and Action Tasks
- Motion by Nearby Players Biases Perception but Not Action in Judgments...
- The type of visual information mediates eye and hand movement bias whe...
- Why are saccades influenced by the Brentano illusion?
- The effect of response uncertainty on illusory biases of perception an...
- The spatio-temporal tuning of the mechanisms in the control of saccadi...
- Dissociating size representation for action and for conscious judgment...
- Hemispheric Specialization for the Visual Control of Action Is Indepen...
- Grasp effects of the Ebbinghaus illusion are ambiguous
- Effect of structuring the workspace on cognitive and sensorimotor dist...
- Visual feedback schedules influence visuomotor resistance to the Mülle...
- Does an auditory perceptual illusion affect on-line auditory action co...
- The effect of the Müller-Lyer illusion on the planning and control of ...
- Toward a formal theory of flexible spatial behavior: Geometric categor...
- MOTION BY NEARBY PLAYERS BIASES PERCEPTION BUT NOT ACTION IN JUDGMENTS...
- Embodiment and Cognitive Science
- Dissociation between Visual Perception of Allocentric Distance and Vis...
- Visual illusions affect both movement planning and on-line control: A ...
- Grasping and Perceiving Objects
- The Medawar Lecture 2001 Knowledge for vision: vision for knowledge
- Effects of the Ebbinghaus figure on grasping are not only due to misju...
- Manual-aiming bias and the Müller-Lyer illusion: the roles of position...
- Effect of Contrast on the Active Control of a Moving Line
- How does action resist visual illusion? Uncorrected oculomotor informa...
- Motion-induced illusory displacement reexamined: differences between p...
- Perception-action and the M�ller-Lyer illusion: amplitude or endpoint ...
- Dual routes to action: contributions of the dorsal and ventral streams...
- Visual phenomenal consciousness: a neurological guided tour
- Hemispheric asymmetry in a dissociation between the visuomotor and vis...
- The Function of Phenomenal States: Supramodular Interaction Theory.
- Psychophysical Test for the Independence of Perception and Action.
- Illusion Effects on Grasping Are Temporally Constant Not Dynamic.
- Perception, Action, and Roelofs Effect: A Mere Illusion of Dissociatio...
- Perceiving virtual geographical slant: Action influences perception.
- An evolving view of duplex vision: separate but interacting cortical p...
- Age-related differences in the visual processes implied in perception ...
- 2D But Not 3D: Pictorial-Depth Deficits in a Case of Visual Agnosia
- Two distinct modes of control for object-directed action
- Visual, haptic and cross-modal recognition of objects and scenes
- Visual Context Integration is Not Fully Developed in 4-Year-Old Childr...
- Direct parameter specification of an attention shift: evidence from pe...
- Grasp effects of the Ebbinghaus illusion: obstacle avoidance is not th...
- When does the Titchener Circles illusion exert an effect on grasping?
- From Vision to Action and Action to Vision: A Convergent Route Approac...
- La dynamique des intentions
- Dissociating perception and action in Kanizsa’s compression illusion
- Insights into Seeing and Grasping: Distinguishing the Neural Correlate...
- Dynamic effects of the Ebbinghaus illusion in grasping: Support for a ...
- A dissociation of perception and action in normal human observers: the...
- Converging evidence for the detection of change without awareness
- Commentary: Smooth pursuit eye movements: from low-level to high-level...
- Selective reaching: Evidence for multiple frames of reference.
- Feature-specific perceptual processing dissociates action from recogni...
- Eye–hand coordination in goal-directed aiming
- Action does not resist visual illusions
- When does action resist visual illusions?
- A Simon effect induced by induced motion and location: Evidence for a ...
- Separate visual representations for perception and action revealed by ...
- Blindsight: the role of feedforward and feedback corticocortical conne...
- Defining the cortical visual systems: “What”, “Where”, and “How”
- Vision: Getting to grips with the Ebbinghaus illusion
- Perception and Action Are Inseparable
- Do action systems resist visual illusions?
- The dissociation between perception and action in the Ebbinghaus illus...
- Chapter 20 Different spaces and different times for perception and act...
- Grasping objects by their handles: A necessary interaction between cog...
- Dynamic illusion effects in a reaching task: Evidence for separate vis...
- Phase correction, phase resetting, and phase shifts after subliminal t...
- Effects of visual illusions on grasping.
- Accommodation, occlusion, and disparity matching are used to guide rea...
- Seeing size and weight
- Varying the response code in the blindness to response-compatible stim...
- Attentional Bias toward Low-Intensity Stimuli: An Explanation for the ...
- Independent effects of pictorial displays on perception and action
- The last grasp?
- Perception-Action Dissociations of a Walkable Müller-Lyer Configuratio...
- Optic Ataxia: A Gateway to the Human Visual Action System
- Influence of Visual Motion on Object Localisation in Perception and Ac...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Get access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
APS members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
APS members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
