Recommendations Implicit in Policy Defaults
Abstract
Should people be considered organ donors after their death unless they request not to be, or should they not be considered donors unless they request to be? Because people tend to stay with the default in a variety of domains, policymakers' choice of default has large and often important effects. In the United States, where the organ-donation policy default is “not a donor,” about 5,000 people die every year because there are too few donors. Four experiments examined two domains—being an organ donor and saving for retirement—where default effects occur and have important implications. The results indicate that default effects occur in part because policymakers' attitudes can be revealed through their choice of default, and people perceive the default as indicating the recommended course of action. Policymakers need to be aware of the implicit messages conveyed by their choice of default.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
REFERENCES
Bellman S., Johnson E.J., Lohse G.L. (2001). To opt-in or opt-out: That depends on the question. Communications of the ACM, 44, 25–27.
Camerer C., Issacharoff S., Loewenstein G., O'Donoghue T., Rabin M. (2003). Regulation for conservatives: Behavioral economics and the case for “asymmetric paternalism.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 151, 1211–1254.
Johnson E.J., Bellman S., Lohse G.L. (2002). Defaults, framing and privacy: Why opting in-opting out. Marketing Letters, 13, 5–15.
Johnson E.J., Goldstein D. (2003). Do defaults save lives? Science, 302, 1338–1339.
Johnson E.J., Hershey J., Meszaros J., Kunreuther H. (1993). Framing, probability distortions, and insurance decisions. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 7, 35–53.
Klassen A.C., Klassen D.K. (1996). Who are the donors in organ donation? The family's perspective in mandated choice. Annals of Internal Medicine, 125, 70–73.
Madrian B.C., Shea D.F. (2001). The power of suggestion: Inertia in 401(k) participation and savings behavior. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116, 1149–1187.
McKenzie C.R.M. (2004). Framing effects in inference tasks—and why they are normatively defensible. Memory & Cognition, 32, 874–885.
McKenzie C.R.M., Nelson J.D. (2003). What a speaker's choice of frame reveals: Reference points, frame selection, and framing effects. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 10, 596–602.
Schkade D.A., Kahneman D. (1998). Does living in California make people happy? A focusing illusion in judgments of life satisfaction. Psychological Science, 9, 340–346.
Sher S. and McKenzie C.R.M. (in press). Information leakage from logically equivalent frames. Cognition.
Sunstein C.R., Thaler R.H. (2003). Libertarian paternalism is not an oxymoron. The University of Chicago Law Review, 70, 1159–1202.
Tversky A., Kahneman D. (1991). Loss aversion in riskless choice: A reference-dependent model. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 106, 1039–1061.
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published: May 2006
Issue published: May 2006
PubMed: 16683929
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Article usage*
Total views and downloads: 3355
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Altmetric
See the impact this article is making through the number of times it’s been read, and the Altmetric Score.
Learn more about the Altmetric Scores
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 253 view articles Opens in new tab
Crossref: 305
- Defending novice user privacy: An evaluation of default web browser co...
- The Power of the Default: Investors’ Reactions to Default Amortization...
- Instilling label confidence in the minds of consumers: The role of sus...
- Hate Trumps Love: The Impact of Political Polarization on Social Prefe...
- The impact of experience on the tendency to accept recommended default...
- Save More Today or Tomorrow: The Role of Urgency in Precommitment Desi...
- Reason Defaults: Presenting Defaults With Reasons for Choosing Each Op...
- Assessing the influence of affective attitudes, demography and blood d...
- “Do it myself” or “do it for me”? : focusing on behavioural and needs ...
- Defaults and effortful tasks
- No trust in the choice architect? No problem! On the minor role of tru...
- The role of autonomy and reactance for nudging — Experimentally compar...
- Reducing single-use cutlery with green nudges: Evidence from China’s f...
- Pay or nudge employees into change? A theoretical and experimental inv...
- The role of attention in status quo bias
- The entrenchment effect: Why people persist with less-preferred behavi...
- Encouraging Individual Contributions to Net-Zero Organizations: Effect...
- Nudge Me If You Can! Why Order Ethicists Should Embrace the Nudge Appr...
- Defaults and cognitive effort
- Nudging App Adoption: Choice Architecture Facilitates Consumer Uptake ...
- Dynamic Currency Conversion Payment Options Specifically Harm Less Fin...
- Cashing Out Retirement Savings at Job Separation
- The joint effect of framing and defaults on choice behavior
- Default settings affect children's decisions about whether to be hones...
- The Effects of Opt-out vs Opt-in Tobacco Treatment on Engagement, Cess...
- Epistemic Libertarian Paternalism
- I'll have what she's having: (Social) Perceptions of default options a...
- Thoughts matter: a theory of motivated preference
- Defaults versus framing: Revisiting Default Effect and Framing Effect ...
- What does the CRT measure? Poor performance may arise from rational pr...
- The Problem
- Challenges for Nudging and a Framework for Assessing Them
- Design propositions for nudging in healthcare: Adoption of national el...
- Reconsidering prosocial behavior as intersocial: A literature review a...
- Eight Misconceptions About Nudges
- Default options and tax avoidance: Evidence from the church tax
- Social Inferences from Choice Context: Dominated Options Can Engender ...
- Nudges jako narzędzia behawioralnej polityki publicznej i ich akceptow...
- Rational Choice in Context
- Nudges and peak pricing: A common pool resource energy conservation ex...
- Incentives in surveys
- Save more with less: The impact of employer defaults and match rates o...
- Odd bedfellows: how choice architecture can enhance autonomy and mitig...
- Nudges as norms: Evidence from the NYC taxi cab industry
- Defaults, disclosures, advice and calculators: One size does not fit a...
- Does default organ donation registration compromise autonomous choice?...
- SkillBot: Identifying Risky Content for Children in Alexa Skills
- Opt-out policy and its improvements promote COVID-19 vaccinations
- “I will pay you more, as long as you are transparent!”: An investigati...
- Nudging for eco-friendly online shopping – Attraction effect curbs pri...
- Priming Engineers to Think About Sustainability: Cognitive and Neuro-C...
- How can carbon labels and climate-friendly default options on restaura...
- A novel opt-in vs opt-out approach to referral-based treatment of toba...
- GMO Labeling Policy and Consumer Choice
- Information defaults in repeated public good provision
- Nudges in SRI: The Power of the Default Option
- Behavioral Insights for Public Policy
- What blood and organ donation can tell us about cooperation?
- Survey Results on Using Nudges for Choice of Green-Energy Supplier
- How we decide shapes what we choose: decision modes track consumer dec...
- If Nudges Treat their Targets as Rational Agents, Nonconsensual Neuroi...
- Leadership selection: Can changing the default break the glass ceiling...
- How to choose a default
- Working Hard to Take the Easy Way Out: How the Need for Cognitive Clos...
- Nudgeability: Mapping Conditions of Susceptibility to Nudge Influence
- Minimum Payments Alter Debt Repayment Strategies Across Multiple Cards
- A 680,000-person megastudy of nudges to encourage vaccination in pharm...
- Privacy and Behavioral Economics
- Framing provides reasons
- The power of defaults in intergroup conflict
- One Size Does Not Fit All: Behavioral Intervention to Promote Vaccinat...
- Organ Donation under Oath
- How do Investors Respond to Default Goodwill Amortization Periods and ...
- When do nudges undermine voluntary consent?
- Options to design more ethical and still successful default nudges: a ...
- Decision-Making Biases and Cyber Attackers
- Making it Easier to Take Environmental Actions is not Enough: Policyma...
- Do nudges make use of automatic processing? Unraveling the effects of ...
- The effects of default choice on student loan borrowing: Experimental ...
- Nudging to donate organs: do what you like or like what we do?
- How far can we get with eco driving tech?
- Can It Clean Up Your Inbox? Evidence from South Korean Anti‐spam Legis...
- Discordance between dementia caregivers’ goal of care and preference f...
- Nudging food waste decisions at restaurants
- Applying behavioral insights to increase rural and remote internships:...
- Nudging Compliance
- The unsolved Hayekian knowledge problem in behavioral economics
- Effects of bin proximity and informational prompts on recycling and co...
- Consumer responses to shopper solutions in service settings
- Legal origins, religion and health outcomes: a cross-country compariso...
- Default sensitivity in attempts at social influence
- Experiencing default nudges: autonomy, manipulation, and choice-satisf...
- Default options and insurance demand
- Who can be nudged? Examining nudging effectiveness in the context of n...
- Increasing people's acceptance of anthropogenic climate change with sc...
- “To Clean or Not to Clean?” Reducing Daily Routine Hotel Room Cleaning...
- The Target Opportunity Costs of Successful Nudges
- Climate-Friendly Default Rules
- Controlling for presentation effects in choice
- Verhaltensökonomisch motivierte Maßnahmen zur Sicherung des Studienerf...
- The myth of individual control: Mapping the limitations of privacy sel...
- Defaults with Misaligned Incentives: The Role of Cognitive Effort
- The Impact of Employer Defaults and Match Rates on Retirement Saving
- Global Giving
- Preference Dynamics in Sequential Consumer Choice with Defaults
- Nudging users into digital service solutions
- Description-dependent preferences
- Nudge for justice: An ERP investigation of default effects on trade-of...
- Two energy suppliers are better than one: Survey experiments on consum...
- When Lone Wolf Defectors Undermine the Power of the Opt-Out Default
- Choose Quickly! The Influence of Cognitive Resource Availability on th...
- Use of Advisors and Retirement Plan Performance
- Teaching temptation bundling to boost exercise: A field experiment
- Nudging: Progress to date and future directions
- Caregiver Preference for Tube Feeding in Community‐Dwelling Persons wi...
- Upselling by Default: The Effect of Default Options on Travelers’ Boar...
- Combining Defaults and Transparency Information to Increase Policy Com...
- A nudge towards better lumbar puncture practice
- Simple nudges that are not so easy
- If It Works, I like It: Consumer Acceptance of Food-Related Nudging
- Active Choice Format and Minimum Payment Warnings in Credit Card Repay...
- Overcoming Status Quo Bias for Resilient Stormwater Infrastructure: Em...
- The Utilization of Robo-Advisors by Individual Investors: An Analysis ...
- Simplification and defaults affect adoption and impact of technology, ...
- Os Vieses Cognitivos e suas Implicações para Educação Financeira: o ca...
- Who is a passive saver under opt-in and auto-enrollment?
- Nudge for Deliberativeness: How Interface Features Influence Online Di...
- The role of perceived effectiveness on the acceptability of choice arc...
- Exploiting asymmetric signals from choices through default selection
- A Maussian bargain: Accumulation by gift in the digital economy
- Gamble evaluation and evoked reference sets: Why adding a small loss t...
- A Review and Framework for Thinking about the Drivers of Prosocial Con...
- Stuck in a Rut: The Behavioral Entrenchment Effect
- This way, please: Uncovering the directional effects of attribute tran...
- Hate Trumps Love: The Impact of Political Polarization on Social Prefe...
- Digital nudging to overcome cognitive resistance in innovation adoptio...
- Escaping Paternalism
- Of promoting networking and protecting privacy: Effects of defaults an...
- Exploring the Impact of (Not) Changing Default Settings in Algorithmic...
- What if you ask and they say yes? Consumers' willingness to disclose p...
- Good job, good pension? The influence of the workplace on saving for r...
- Transparency effects on policy compliance: disclosing how defaults wor...
- When and why defaults influence decisions: a meta-analysis of default ...
- How green defaults promote environmentally friendly decisions: Attitud...
- Ethical defaults: which transparency components can increase the effec...
- Generous by default: A field experiment on designing defaults that ali...
- Nudges and signposts: The effect of smart defaults and pictographic ri...
- On Nudging’s Supposed Threat to Rational Decision-Making
- Getting Real on Rationality—Behavioral Science, Nudging, and Public Po...
- Harnessing behavioural insights to encourage consumer engagement in th...
- Better Government, Better Science: The Promise of and Challenges Facin...
- Nudging tourists to donate for conservation: Experimental evidence on ...
- Got a dollar? Locomotion orientation decreases the effect of defaults ...
- The power of active choice: Field experimental evidence on repeated co...
- What Determines Support for Donor Registration Systems? The Influence ...
- Does the GDPR Enhance Consumers’ Control over Personal Data? An Analys...
- How incentive framing can harness the power of social norms
- Fight to Be Forgotten: Exploring the Efficacy of Data Erasure in Popul...
- New Media Environments and Their Threats
- Spreading of Alternatives Without a Perception of Choice
- Improving acceptability of nudges: Learning from attitudes towards opt...
- Generous to a Fault? The Effect of Generosity of Employers’ Retirement...
- The Role of Autonomy and Reactance for Nudging - Experimentally Compar...
- Beyond Willpower: Strategies for Reducing Failures of Self-Control
- Prepopulating Audit Workpapers with Prior Year Assessments: Default Op...
- Choice defaults and social consensus effects on online information sha...
- The future of behavioral insights: on the importance of socially situa...
- Process Utility and the Effect of Inaction Frames
- Nudging generosity: Choice architecture and cognitive factors in chari...
- Effect of default menus on food selection and consumption in a college...
- Translated Attributes as Choice Architecture: Aligning Objectives and ...
- I Have, Therefore I Love: Status Quo Preference in Mate Choice
- Can nudges be transparent and yet effective?
- Why do we do what we do? The Attention–Readiness–Motivation framework
- The Application of Optimal Defaults to Improve Elementary School Lunch...
- A Randomized Controlled Trial of Opt-In Versus Opt-Out Enrollment Into...
- Intentional Choice Architecture
- Opportunities for greater energy efficiency in government facilities b...
- Privacy in Social Information Access
- Rational Choice Explained and Defended
- Mapping the Privacy Rationales
- Point at, Nudge, or Push Private Provisions to a Public Good? Field Ex...
- Norm Uncertainty and Pro-Social Behavior in Charitable Giving
- Legal Origins, Religion and Health Outcomes: A Cross-Country Compariso...
- How Incentive Framing Can Harness the Power of Social Norms
- Default neglect in attempts at social influence
- Defaults and advice in self-customization procedures of insurance
- Do target date mutual funds meet their targets?
- Changing the default for tobacco-cessation treatment in an inpatient s...
- When Do People Prefer Carrots to Sticks? A Robust “Matching Effect” in...
- The Role of Inference in Attribute Framing Effects
- Choice Architecture 2.0: Behavioral Policy as an Implicit Social Inter...
- CHARITABLE GIVING, EMOTIONS, AND THE DEFAULT EFFECT
- Defaults in Green Electricity Markets: Preference Match Not Guaranteed
- Sharing is daring: An experiment on consent, chilling effects and a sa...
- Analyzing and Optimizing Access Control Choice Architectures in Online...
- Put the healthy item first: Order of ingredient listing influences con...
- The application of defaults to optimize parents' health-based choices ...
- Nudges that fail
- The limit to behavioral inertia and the power of default in voluntary ...
- Adjustable Green Defaults Can Help Make Smart Homes More Sustainable
- Behaviorally Informed Policies for Household Financial Decisionmaking
- Choice Architecture as a Strategy to Encourage Elegant Infrastructure ...
- Green nudges: Do they work? Are they ethical?
- Must-Opt Imperatives and Other Stories Make Passengers of Low Cost Car...
- Is This Technology Useless? How Seemingly Irrelevant Factors Affect Ad...
- Does Nudging Intentions Translate into Action? Why Nudging Pledges to ...
- Competing by Default: A New Way to Break the Glass Ceiling
- Misconceptions About Nudges
- How Do Consumers Respond When Default Options Push the Envelope?
- Challenges in Ensuring Financial Competencies: Essays on How to Measur...
- Should I Give or How Much Should I Give? Continuous (versus Discrete) ...
- Simplification and Defaults Affect Adoption and Impact of Technology, ...
- A Review and Taxonomy of Choice Architecture Techniques
- WHY BEHAVIOURAL POLICY NEEDS MECHANISTIC EVIDENCE
- The Ethics of Organ Donor Registration Policies: Nudges and Respect fo...
- Ethically Deployed Defaults: Transparency and Consumer Protection thro...
- When should the Ask be a Nudge? The Effect of Default Amounts on Chari...
- Default Clinic Appointments Promote Influenza Vaccination Uptake witho...
- Nudge me if you can - how defaults and attitude strength interact to c...
- Online purchasing creates opportunities to lower the life cycle carbon...
- Exploring Psychology in the Field: Steps and Examples From the Used‐Ca...
- Anchoring in Payment: Evaluating a Judgmental Heuristic in Field Exper...
- Time delay, complexity and support for taxation
- The current status and future perspectives of organ donation in Japan:...
- Nudge Versus Boost: How Coherent are Policy and Theory?
- Can indifference make the world greener?
- Privacy Behaviour and Profile Configuration in Twitter
- Default-Switching: The Hidden Cost of Defaults
- Green Nudges: Do They Work? Are They Ethical?
- Climate-Friendly Default Rules
- Can Nudges Be Transparent and Yet Effective?
- Prepopulating Current Year Workpapers with Prior Year Audit Results: E...
- The Power of Active Choice: Field Experimental Evidence on Repeated Co...
- American attitudes toward nudges
- Behaviorally Green: Why, Which and When Defaults Can Help
- A User's Guide to Debiasing
- The promise of asymmetric interventions for addressing risks to enviro...
- Feeding Strategies Derived from Behavioral Economics and Psychology Ca...
- The Ethical Merits of Nudges in the Clinical Setting
- Well-Endowed Rating Systems: How Modified Defaults Can Lead to More Su...
- On the Supposed Evidence for Libertarian Paternalism
- Simplifying Data Disclosure Configurations in a Cloud Computing Enviro...
- Social negative option marketing
- THE ROLE OF DEFAULTS IN PREVENTING INNOVATION REJECTION
- Warning: You are about to be Nudged
- It's time to change the default for tobacco treatment
- Doing good by doing nothing? The role of social norms in explaining de...
- Privacy and human behavior in the age of information
- Bundling Public with Private Goods
- When Do People Prefer Carrots to Sticks? A Robust 'Matching Effect' in...
- Charitable Giving, Emotions, and the Default Effect
- Are default contributions sticky? An experimental analysis of defaults...
- Changing the default setting for information privacy protection: What ...
- An international comparison of deceased and living organ donation/tran...
- Envision As Choice Architecture: Can Smarter Defaults Lead to More Sus...
- Social Defaults: Observed Choices Become Choice Defaults
- Framing Options as Choice or Opportunity...
- Change and status quo in decisions with defaults: The effect of incide...
- Minimum Payment Warnings and Information Disclosure Effects on Consume...
- Personal traits and individual choices: Taking action in economic and ...
- Better Medicine by Default
- Warning: You are About to Be Nudged
- The Council of Psychological Advisers
- Defaults and Donations: Evidence from a Field Experiment
- Identifying Essential and Optional Decision Constructs in On-line Tran...
- Testing the effect of defaults on the thermostat settings of OECD empl...
- Libertarian Paternalism, Information Production, and Financial Decisio...
- Choice without Awareness: Ethical and Policy Implications of Defaults
- Incentivizing Wellness in the Workplace...
- On the descriptive value of loss aversion in decisions under risk: Six...
- Awareness of Legislation Moderates the Effect of Opt-Out Consent on Or...
- Bundling Public with Private Goods
- Tearing the Veil of Privacy Law: An Experiment on Chilling Effects and...
- Can Indifference Make the World Greener?
- Heuristics and Life-Sustaining Treatments
- The meaning of default options for potential organ donors
- The default pull: An experimental demonstration of subtle default effe...
- The effect of default options on choice—Evidence from online product c...
- Labeling of Nanotechnology Consumer Products Can Influence Risk and Be...
- Trust and self-control: The moderating role of the default
- Enhanced active choice: A new method to motivate behavior change
- Entscheidungsverhalten von Kunden in Mass Customization-Systemen
- Misunderstanding Savings Growth: Implications for Retirement Savings ...
- Minimum Required Payment and Supplemental Information Disclosure Effec...
- Improving Response Rates in Web Surveys with Default Setting: The Effe...
- On the Descriptive Value of Loss Aversion in Decisions under Risk
- Judgment and Decision Making
- Message Framing, Normative Advocacy and Persuasive Success
- Order in Product Customization Decisions: Evidence from Field Experime...
- Partitioning Default Effects: Why People Choose Not to Choose
- Libertarian Paternalism, Information Sharing, and Financial Decision-M...
- Retirement Savings Investment Choices in Response to the Global Financ...
- Fast and Frugal Heuristics: Tools of Social Rationality
- Is default risk acceptable when purchasing insurance? Experimental evi...
- Speaker–listener incompatibility: Joint and separate processing in ris...
- Die Macht des Defaults — Wirkung von Empfehlungen und Vorgaben auf das...
- Green defaults: Information presentation and pro-environmental behavio...
- Emotional tone and argumentation in risk communication
- Man, my brain is tired: Linking depletion and cognitive effort in choi...
- The Influence of Default Options on the Expression of End-of-Life Trea...
- The Default Effect in End-of-Life Medical Treatment Preferences
- How Can Measures of Subjective Well-Being Be Used to Inform Public Pol...
- The Economist as Therapist: Methodological Ramifications of 'Light' Pa...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Get access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
APS members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
APS members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
