Putting the “Management” Back in Human Resource Management: A Review and Agenda for Future Research
Abstract
Although much research has examined human resource management (HRM), managers’ roles in HRM seem to have been ancillary to this area of research. That is, HRM theory and research largely has advanced with a focus on policies, practices, systems, and their implementation and effectiveness, with less attention focused on the managers responsible for the design, adoption, enactment, and implementation of HRM strategy and practice. The purpose of this review is to examine extant research to determine the state of knowledge of the role of managers across organizational hierarchy in HRM. Thus, we review empirical literature for studies that include aspects of the impact lower-to-middle managers, human resource managers, top management teams, CEOs, and boards of directors have on HRM content, process, and outcomes. On the basis of the findings of this systematic, multilevel review, we discuss avenues for future research at each specific manager’s level, as well as general opportunities and challenges for research on managers’ roles in HRM across all hierarchical levels.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
References marked with an asterisk indicate studies included in the review.
Aguinis H., Ramani R. S., Alabduljader N. 2018. What you see is what you get? Enhancing methodological transparency in management research. The Academy of Management Annals, 12: 83-110.
*Alfes K., Shantz A. D., Truss C., Soane E. C. 2013. The link between perceived human resource management practices engagement and employee behavior: A moderated mediation model. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 24: 330-351.
*Alfes K., Truss C., Soane E. C., Rees C., Gatenby M. 2013. The relationship between line manager behavior, perceived HRM practices, and individual performance: Examining the mediating role of engagement. Human Resource Management, 52: 839-859.
*Ali M., Konrad A. M. 2017. Antecedents and consequences of diversity and equality management systems: The importance of gender diversity in the TMT and lower to middle management. European Management Journal, 35: 440-453.
*Arthur J. B., Herdman A. O., Yang J. 2016. How top management HR beliefs and values affect high-performance work system adoption and implementation effectiveness. Human Resource Management, 55: 413-435.
*Azmi F. T., Mushtaq S. 2015. Role of line managers in human resource management: Empirical evidence from India. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 26: 616-639.
*Barrick M. R., Thurgood G. R., Smith T. A., Courtright S. H. 2015. Collective organizational engagement: Linking motivational antecedents, strategic implementation, and firm performance. Academy of Management Journal, 58: 111-135.
Bass B. M. 1998. Transformational leadership: Industrial, military, and educational impact. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Baur J. E., Ellen B. P. III, Buckley M. R., Ferris G. R., Allison T. H., McKenny A. F., Short J. C. 2016. More than one way to articulate a vision: A configurations approach to leader charismatic rhetoric and influence. The Leadership Quarterly, 27: 156-171.
Becker B. E., Huselid M. A. 2006. Strategic human resources management: Where do we go from here? Journal of Management, 32: 898-925.
*Bennington L. 2006. HRM role in EEO: Sheep in shepherd’s clothing? Journal of Business Ethics, 65: 13-21.
*Bjorkman I., Ehrnrooth M., Smale A., John S. 2011. The determinants of line management internalisation of HRM practices in MNC subsidiaries. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 22: 1654-1671.
Boada-Cuerva M., Trullen J., Valverde M. in press. Top management: The missing stakeholder in the HRM literature. The International Journal of Human Resource Management.
*Bos-Nehles A. C., Van Riemsdijk M. J., Looise J. K. 2013. Employee perceptions of line management performance: Applying the AMO theory to explain the effectiveness of line managers’ HRM implementation. Human Resource Management, 52: 861-877.
Bowen D. E., Ostroff C. 2004. Understanding HRM–firm performance linkages: The role of the “strength” of the HRM system. Academy of Management Review, 29: 203-221.
*Brandl J., Madsen M. T., Madsen H. 2009. The perceived importance of HR duties to Danish line managers. Human Resource Management Journal, 19: 194-210.
*Brewster C., Brookes M., Gollan P. J. 2015. The institutional antecedents of the assignment of HRM responsibilities to line managers. Human Resource Management, 54: 577-597.
Brown M. E., Treviño L. K., Harrison D. A. 2005. Ethical leadership: A social learning perspective for construct development and testing. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 97: 117-134.
Busenbark J. R., Krause R., Boivie S., Graffin S. D. 2016. Toward a configurational perspective on the CEO: A review and synthesis of the management literature. Journal of Management, 42: 234-268.
*Camelo-Ordaz C., Fernández-Alles M. D. L. L., Valle-Cabrera R. 2008. Top management team’s vision and human resources management practices in innovative Spanish companies. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 19: 620-638.
*Carmeli A. 2008. Top management team behavioral integration and the performance of service organizations. Group & Organization Management, 33: 712-735.
*Carmeli A., Tishler A. 2006. The relative importance of the top management team’s managerial skills. International Journal of Manpower, 27: 9-36.
Carpenter M. A., Sanders W. M. 2002. Top management team compensation: The missing link between CEO pay and firm performance? Strategic Management Journal, 23: 367-375.
*Caza A. 2011. Testing alternate predictions for the performance consequences of middle managers’ discretion. Human Resource Management, 50: 9-28.
*Chadwick C., Super J. F., Kwon K. 2015. Resource orchestration in practice: CEO emphasis on SHRM, commitment-based HR systems, and firm performance. Strategic Management Journal, 36: 360-376.
Chen G., Kanfer R. 2006. Toward a systems theory of motivated behavior in work teams. Research in Organizational Behavior, 27: 223-267.
*Chen Y., Hsu Y., Yip F. W. 2011. Friends or rivals: Comparative perceptions of human resource and line managers on perceived future firm performance. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 22: 1703-1722.
*Chuang C. H., Jackson S. E., Jiang Y. 2016. Can knowledge-intensive teamwork be managed? Examining the roles of HRM systems, leadership, and tacit knowledge. Journal of Management, 42: 524-554.
*Cogin J. A., Sanders K., Williamson I. O. 2018. Work-life support practices and customer satisfaction: The role of TMT composition and country culture. Human Resource Management, 57: 279-291.
*Crawshaw J. R., Game A. 2015. The role of line managers in employee career management: An attachment theory perspective. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 26: 1182-1203.
*Dany F., Guedri Z., Hatt F. 2008. New insights into the link between HRM integration and organizational performance: The moderating role of influence distribution between HRM specialists and line managers. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 19: 2095-2112.
*Darwish T. K., Singh S. 2013. Does strategic human resource involvement and devolvement enhance organizational performance? Evidence from Jordan. International Journal of Manpower, 34: 674-692.
*Den Hartog D. N., Boon C., Verburg R. M., Croon M. A. 2013. HRM, communication, satisfaction, and perceived performance: A cross-level test. Journal of Management, 39: 1637-1665.
*Dewettinck K., Vroonen W. 2017. Antecedents and consequences of performance management enactment by front-line managers: Evidence from Belgium. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 28: 2473-2502.
*Do H., Budhwar P. S., Patel C. 2018. Relationship between innovation-led HR policy, strategy, and firm performance: A serial mediation investigation. Human Resource Management, 57: 1271-1284.
*Dysvik A., Kuvaas B. 2012. Perceived supervisor support climate, perceived investment in employee development climate, and business-unit performance. Human Resource Management, 51: 651-664.
*Everly B. A., Schwarz J. L. 2015. Predictors of the adoption of LGBT-friendly HR policies. Human Resource Management, 54: 367-384.
*Farndale E., Kelliher C. 2013. Implementing performance appraisal: Exploring the employee experience. Human Resource Management, 52: 879-897.
*Frear K. A., Cao Y., Zhao W. 2012. CEO background and the adoption of Western-style human resource practices in China. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 23: 4009-4024.
Gangloff K. A., Connelly B. L., Shook C. L. 2016. Of scapegoats and signals: Investor reactions to CEO succession in the aftermath of wrongdoing. Journal of Management, 42: 1614-1634.
*Gilbert C., De Winne S., Sels L. 2011a. Antecedents of front-line managers’ perceptions of HR role stressors. Personnel Review, 40: 549-569.
*Gilbert C., De Winne S., Sels L. 2011b. The influence of line managers and HR department on employees’ affective commitment. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 22: 1618-1637.
*Gilbert C., De Winne S., Sels L. 2015. Strong HRM processes and line managers’ effective HRM implementation: A balanced view. Human Resource Management Journal, 25: 600-616.
Gill C., Gardner W., Claeys J., Vangronsvelt L. 2018. Using theory on authentic leadership to build a strong human resource management system. Human Resource Management Review, 28: 304-318.
*Gould J. A., Kulik C. T., Sardeshmukh S. R. 2018. Trickle-down effect: The impact of female board members on executive gender diversity. Human Resource Management, 57: 931-945.
Guest D. E. 1997. Human resource management and performance: A review and research agenda. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 8: 263-276.
*Guest D. E., Conway N. 2011. The impact of HR practices, HR effectiveness and a “strong HR system” on organizational outcomes: A stakeholder perspective. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 22: 1686-1702.
Hales C. 2005. Rooted in supervision, branching into management: Continuity and change in the role of first-line manager. Journal of Management Studies, 42: 471-506.
Hambrick D. C. 2007. Upper echelons theory: An update. Academy of Management Review, 32: 334-343.
*Han J. H., Bartol K. M., Kim S. 2015. Tightening up the performance-pay linkage: Roles of contingent reward leadership and profit-sharing in the cross-level influence of individual pay-for-performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 100: 417-430.
Han J. H., Liao H., Taylor M. S., Kim S. 2018. Effects of high-performance work systems on transformational leadership and team performance: Investigating the moderating roles of organizational orientations. Human Resource Management, 57: 1065-1082.
Hillman A. J., Dalziel T. 2003. Boards of directors and firm performance: Integrating agency and resource dependence perspectives. Academy of Management Review, 28: 383-396.
Hillman A. J., Nicholson G., Shropshire C. 2008. Directors’ multiple identities, identification, and board monitoring and resource provision. Organization Science, 19: 441-456.
Hogan J., Martínez Lucio M. 2007. Human resource management. In Ritzer G. (Ed.), The Blackwell encyclopedia of sociology. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell.
*Hong Y., Liao H., Raub S., Han J. H. 2016. What it takes to get proactive: An integrative multilevel model of the antecedents of personal initiative. Journal of Applied Psychology, 101: 687-701.
*Huselid M. A., Jackson S. E., Schuler R. S. 1997. Technical and strategic human resources management effectiveness as determinants of firm performance. Academy of Management Journal, 40: 171-188.
Jackson S. E., Schuler R. S., Jiang K. 2014. An aspirational framework for strategic human resource management. The Academy of Management Annals, 8: 1-56.
*Jiang K., Chuang C. H., Chiao Y. C. 2015. Developing collective customer knowledge and service climate: The interaction between service-oriented high-performance work systems and service leadership. Journal of Applied Psychology, 100: 1089-1106.
Kanter R. M. 1977. Men and women of the corporation. New York: Basic Books.
*Khavul S., Benson G. S., Datta D. K. 2010. Is internationalization associated with investments in HRM? A study of entrepreneurial firms in emerging markets. Human Resource Management, 49: 693-713.
*Konrad A. M., Linnehan F. 1995. Formalized HRM structures: Coordinating equal employment opportunity or concealing organizational practices? Academy of Management Journal, 38: 787-820.
*Kulik C. T., Cregan C., Metz I., Brown M. 2009. HR managers as toxin handlers: The buffering effect of formalizing toxin handling responsibilities. Human Resource Management, 48: 695-716.
*Kuvaas B., Dysvik A. 2010. Exploring alternative relationships between perceived investment in employee development, perceived supervisor support and employee outcomes. Human Resource Management Journal, 20: 138-156.
*Kuvaas B., Dysvik A., Buch R. 2014. Antecedents and employee outcomes of line managers’ perceptions of enabling HR practices. Journal of Management Studies, 51: 845-868.
Lado A. A., Wilson M. C. 1994. Human resource systems and sustained competitive advantage: A competency-based perspective. Academy of Management Review, 19: 699-727.
*Leisink P. L. M., Knies E. 2011. Line managers’ support for older workers. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 22: 1902-1917.
Lengnick-Hall C. A., Lengnick-Hall M. L. 1988. Strategic human resources management: A review of the literature and a proposed typology. Academy of Management Review, 13: 454-470.
Lepak D. P., Snell S. A. 1999. The human resource architecture: Toward a theory of human capital allocation and development. Academy of Management Review, 24: 31-48.
Lepak D. P., Snell S. A. 2002. Examining the human resource architecture: The relationships among human capital, employment, and human resource configurations. Journal of Management, 28: 517-543.
Li X., Frenkel S. J., Sanders K. 2011. Strategic HRM as process: How HR system and organizational climate strength influence Chinese employee attitudes. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 22: 1825-1842.
*Lievens F., Corte W. D. 2008. Development and test of a model of external organizational commitment in human resources outsourcing. Human Resource Management, 47: 559-579.
*Lopez-Cabrales A., Bornay-Barrachina M., Diaz-Fernandez M. 2017. Leadership and dynamic capabilities: The role of HR systems. Personnel Review, 46: 255-276.
*Mayo M., Pastor J., Gomez-Mejia L., Cruz C. 2009. Why some firms adopt telecommuting while others do not: A contingency perspective. Human Resource Management, 48: 917-939.
Messersmith J. G., Patel P. C., Lepak D. P., Gould-Williams J. S. 2011. Unlocking the black box: Exploring the link between high-performance work systems and performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96: 1105-1118.
*Michiels A. 2017. Formal compensation practices in family SMEs. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 24: 88-104.
Miller D. T., Effron D. A. 2010. Psychological license: When it is needed and how it functions. In Zanna M. P., Olson J. M. (Eds.), Advances in experimental social psychology, vol. 43: 115-155. San Diego: Elsevier.
*Milliken F. J., Martins L. L., Morgan H. 1998. Explaining organizational responsiveness to work-family issues: The role of human resource executives as issue interpreters. Academy of Management Journal, 41: 580-592.
*Mullins F. 2018. HR on board! The implications of human resource expertise on boards of directors for diversity management. Human Resource Management, 57: 1127-1143.
*Mullins F., Holmes J. 2018. Balancing board? The effects of board independence and capital on firms offering work-family benefits. Human Resource Management, 57: 457-469.
*Neves P., Almeida P., Velez M. J. 2018. Reducing intentions to resist future change: Combined effects of commitment-based HR practices and ethical leadership. Human Resource Management, 57: 249-261.
*Ng E. S., Sears G. J. 2012. CEO leadership styles and the implementation of organizational diversity practices: Moderating effects of social values and age. Journal of Business Ethics, 105: 41-52.
Nishii L. H., Wright P. 2008. Variability at multiple levels of analysis: Implications for strategic human resource management. In Smith D. B. (Ed.), The people make the place: Dynamic linkages between individuals and organizations: 225-248. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
*Op de Beeck S., Wynen J., Hondeghem A. 2016. HRM implementation by line managers: Explaining the discrepancy in HR-line perceptions of HR devolution. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 27: 1901-1919.
*Ordiz-Fuertes M., Fernández-Sánchez E. 2003. High-involvement practices in human resource management: Concept and factors that motivate their adoption. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 14: 511-529.
Ostroff C., Bowen D. E. 2016. Reflections on the 2014 decade award: Is there strength in the construct of HR system strength? Academy of Management Review, 41: 196-214.
*Pak J., Kim S. 2018. Team manager’s implementation, high performance work systems intensity, and performance: A multilevel investigation. Journal of Management, 44: 2690-2715.
*Perry E. L., Kulik C. T. 2008. The devolution of HR to the line: Implications for perceptions of people management effectiveness. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 19: 262-273.
Posthuma R. A., Campion M. C., Masimova M., Campion M. A. 2013. A high performance work practices taxonomy: Integrating the literature and directing future research. Journal of Management, 39: 1184-1220.
*Prieto-Pastor I., Martin-Perez V. 2015. Does HRM generate ambidextrous employees for ambidextrous learning? The moderating role of management support. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 26: 589-615.
*Reichel A., Lazarova M. 2013. The effects of outsourcing and devolvement on the strategic position of HR departments. Human Resource Management, 52: 923-946.
Russell Z. A., Steffensen D. S., Ellen B. P. III, Zhang L., Ferris G. R., Bishoff J. 2018. High performance work practice implementation and employee impressions of line manager leadership. Human Resource Management Review, 28: 258-270.
*Ryu S., Kim S. 2013. First-line managers’ HR involvement and HR effectiveness: The case of South Korea. Human Resource Management, 52: 947-966.
*Sheehan C., Cooper B., Holland P., Cieri H. D. 2007. The relationship between HRM avenues of political influence and perceived organizational performance. Human Resource Management, 46: 611-629.
*Shipton H., Sanders K., Atkinson C., Frenkel S. 2016. Sense-giving in health care: The relationship between the HR roles of line managers and employee commitment. Human Resource Management Journal, 26: 29-45.
*Sikora D. M., Ferris G. R. 2011. Critical factors in human resource practice implementation: Implications of cross-cultural contextual issues. International Journal of Human Resources Development and Management, 11: 112-140.
*Sikora D. M., Ferris G. R., Van Iddekinge C. H. 2015. Line manager implementation perceptions as a mediator of relations between high-performance work practices and employee outcomes. Journal of Applied Psychology, 100: 1908-1918.
*Snell S. A., Youndt M. A. 1995. Human resource management and firm performance: Testing a contingency model of executive controls. Journal of Management, 21: 711-737.
*Stirpe L., Trullen J., Bonache J. 2013. Factors helping the HR function gain greater acceptance for its proposals and innovations: Evidence from Spain. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 24: 3794-3811.
Su Z. X., Wright P. M., Ulrich M. D. 2018. Going beyond the SHRM paradigm: Examining four approaches to governing employees. Journal of Management, 44: 1598-1619.
Tepper B. J. 2000. Consequences of abusive supervision. Academy of Management Journal, 43: 178-190.
*Tsao C., Chen S., Wang Y. 2016. Family governance oversight, performance, and high performance work systems. Journal of Business Research, 69: 2130-2137.
Ulrich D. 1997. Human resource champions: The next agenda for adding value to HR practices. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
*Vermeeren B. 2014. Variability in HRM implementation among line managers and its effect on performance: A 2-1-2 mediational multilevel approach. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 25: 3039-3059.
*Welbourne T. M., Cyr L. A. 1999. The human resource executive effect in initial public offering firms. Academy of Management Journal, 42: 616-629.
Wooldridge B., Schmid T., Floyd S. W. 2008. The middle management perspective on strategy process: Contributions, synthesis, and future research. Journal of Management, 34: 1190-1221.
Wright P. M., McMahan G. C. 1992. Theoretical perspectives for strategic human resource management. Journal of Management, 18: 295-320.
*Xi M., Zhao S., Xu Q. 2017. The influence of CEO relationship-focused behaviors on firm performance: A chain-mediating role of employee relations climate and employees’ attitudes. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 34: 173-192.
*Zhu W., Chew I. K., Spangler W. D. 2005. CEO transformational leadership and organizational outcomes: The mediating role of human–capital-enhancing human resource management. The Leadership Quarterly, 16: 39-52.
Supplementary Material
Supplemental material files:
Summary
Supplemental material for this article is available with the manuscript on the JOM website.
Resources
File (jom816179_sm.pdf)
- Download
- 605.28 KB
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published online: January 3, 2019
Issue published: July 2019
Keywords
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Article usage*
Total views and downloads: 11501
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Altmetric
See the impact this article is making through the number of times it’s been read, and the Altmetric Score.
Learn more about the Altmetric Scores
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 60 view articles Opens in new tab
Crossref: 62
- Context is key: A 34‐country analysis investigating how similar ...
- Answerable for what? The role of accountab...
- Humour and Psychological Well-being: The Intervening Role of Gender an...
- Paternalism as a positive way of HRM in MSMEs during the COVID-19 pand...
- Complementary effects of high‐performance work systems ...
- Practical Illustration and Future Direction of the Integrated Evaluati...
- CEO entrepreneurial orientation, human resource manageme...
- A multi-actor perspective on the effectiveness of human resource manag...
- The impact of different components of HRM strength on employee burnout...
- Cybersecurity research from a management perspective: A systematic lit...
- Exploring the socio‐political dynamics of front‐line managers’ HR invo...
- Organizational social activities and knowledge management behaviors: A...
- Middle managers as key talent management stakeholders: Navigating para...
- Strategy-Making and Organizational Evolution
- How can CEOs influence HRM implementation? Unfolding top management’s ...
- Capability bundling for effective supply chain management: An integrat...
- How line-manager leadership styles and employee-perceived HRM practice...
- Don’t Worry, Be Happy—Does the CEO’s Personality Mitigate the Negative...
- Does it take two to tango? The joint role of high-performance work sys...
- The role of leadership in human resource management: perspectives and ...
- The impact of flexibility-oriented HRM systems on innovative behaviour...
- The influence of the fit between strategic human resource management a...
- Toward a non‐organizational theory of human resource management? A com...
- Work transformation and the HR ecosystem dynamics: A longitudinal case...
- Training Priority for Managerial Competence of Nurse Managers in Sma...
- Composing the same song: when and how high-performance work systems ca...
- Skills-based volunteering: A systematic literature review of the inter...
- The framework of first-line manager's HR role identity: A Multi-actor ...
- The more the better? How and when can high-performance work systems fu...
- The trickle‐down effect of managers' belief in the importance of human...
- HRM in entrepreneurial firms: A systematic review and research agenda
- Positive psychology and human resource management: Building an HR arch...
- Incongruous employer brand signals and organizational attractiveness: ...
- Human Resource Management, Leadership and Knowledge Management: Never ...
- CHRO firm dinosaur versus CHRO role gorilla: the effect of CHRO compan...
- Talent management in turbulent times: Selection, negotiation, and expl...
- What helps managers being fair? Predicting managers’ self-reported jus...
- Deep Neural Network Model Construction for Digital Human Resource Mana...
- À métier spécifique, gestion spécifique ? Le cas des designers User eX...
- Small firms, owner managers and (strategic?) human resource management
- The road taken and the path forward for HR devolution research: An evo...
- HRM system strength and employee well‐being: the role of internal proc...
- Responsible Leadership Fuels Innovative Behavior: The Mediating Roles ...
- Agile for HR: Fine in practice, but will it work in theory?
- Navigating the shifting landscapes of HRM
- Is unethical leadership a negative for Employees' personal growth and ...
- How symbolic human resource function actions affect the implementation...
- Managers' sexually-oriented behavior and firm performance: linking med...
- An Attention-Based View of Strategic Human Resource Management
- A new look at the relationships between transformational leadership an...
- The cyber-work performance of managers in education
- Human resource management in project-based organizations: revisiting t...
- How Symbolic Human Resource Function Actions Affect the Implementation...
- A quarter‐century review of HRM in small and medium‐size...
- The role of the board chair—A literature review and suggestions for fu...
- The role of leadership in human resource management: perspectives and ...
- From Intended to Actual and Beyond: A Cross‐Disciplinary View of (Huma...
- Line management involvement in performance appraisal work
- The real problem: The deadly combination of psychologisation, scientis...
- How Ethical Leadership Shapes Employees’ Readiness to Change: The Medi...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Get access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
SMA members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
SMA members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
