Personal Income Tax Revenue Growth and Volatility: Lessons and Insights from Utah Tax Reform

First Published September 19, 2016 Research Article

Authors

1
 
Romney Institute of Public Management, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT, USA
by this author
, 2
 
Taxometry, Salt Lake City, UT, USA
by this author
, 1
 
Romney Institute of Public Management, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT, USA
by this author
First Published Online: September 19, 2016

In order to reduce the volatility of the personal income tax in Utah, review and reform efforts recommended a simple flat tax that disallowed all deductions or exemptions. Among the reasons for the recommended flat tax was the argument that it would result in a more stable year-over-year tax revenue stream. This was especially important for education financing. The tax system that was finally adopted retained exemptions and deductions through a tax credit. Using a series of simulations based on twenty-one years of tax returns, we establish that by retaining exemptions and deductions, tax reform efforts failed to appreciably reduce the volatility of personal income tax revenues. These simulations also show that the initially proposed flat income tax with no exemptions or deductions would have decreased volatility at the cost of reducing the growth rate. This study contributes insights, caveats, methodology, and potential alternatives for future individual income tax reforms by focusing on the growth and volatility of three different tax systems.

Alm, James . 1996. “What Is an Optimal Tax System?” National Tax Journal 49:11733.
Google Scholar | ISI
Braunstein, Elissa . 2004. “What Caused the Massachusetts Fiscal Crisis?” Challenge 47:1740.
Google Scholar | Crossref
Brunori, Davd . 2011. State Tax Policy. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press.
Google Scholar
Carroll, Deborah . 2005. “Are State Governments Prepared for Fiscal Crises? A Look at Revenue Diversification during the 1990s.” Public Finance Review 33:60333.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals
Carroll, Robert, Wasylenko, Michael. 1994. “Do State Business Climates Still Matter? Evidence of a Structural Change.” National Tax Journal 47:1937.
Google Scholar | ISI
Cornia, Gary, Nelson, Ray, 2010. “State Tax Growth and Volatility.” Regional Economic Development 6:2358.
Google Scholar
Cornia, Gary, Nelson, Ray, Wilko, Andrea. 2004. “Fiscal Planning, Budgeting and Rebudgeting Using Revenue Semaphores.” Public Administration Review 64:16479.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Crain, W. Mark . 2003. Volatile States: Institutions, Policy, and the Performance of American State Economies. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press.
Google Scholar | Crossref
Dahl, Gordon B., Ransom, Michael R.. 1999. “Does Where You Stand Depend on Where You Sit? Tithing Donations and Self-serving Beliefs.” American Economic Review 89:70327.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Diamond, Peter, Saez, Emmanuel. 2015. “The Case for a Progressive Tax: From Basic Research to Policy Recommendations.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 25:16590.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Dye, Richard F., McGuire, Therese J.. 1991. “Growth and Variability of State Individual Income and General Sales Taxes.” National Tax Journal 44:5566.
Google Scholar | ISI
Gale, William G., Krupkin, Aaron, Ruben, Kim. 2015. The Relationship between Taxes and Growth at the State Level: New Evidence. Washington, DC: Tax Policy Center, Urban Institute and Brookings Institution.
Google Scholar
Gale, William G., Samwick, Andrew A.. 2014. Effects of Income Tax Changes on Economic Growth. Washington, DC: Economic Studies at Brookings.
Google Scholar | Crossref
Gamage, David . 2010. “Preventing State Budget Crisis: Managing the Fiscal Volatility Problem.” California Law Review 98:749812.
Google Scholar | ISI
Graetz, Michael J. 2007. “Tax Reform Unraveling.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 21(1): 6990.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Groves, Harold, Harry Kahn, C.. 1952. “The Stability of State and Local Tax Yields.” American Economic Review 42:87102.
Google Scholar | ISI
Helms, L. Jay . 1985. “The Effect of State and Local Taxes on Economic Growth: A Time Series-cross Section Approach.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 67:292312.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Holcombe, Randall G., Lacombe, Donald. 2004. “The Effect of State Income Taxation on Per Capita Income Growth.” Public Finance Review 32:292312.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals
Keen, Michael, Papapanagos, Harry, Shorrocks, Anthony. 2000. “Tax Reform and Progressivity.” The Economic Journal 110:5068.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Madsen, Peter, Desai, Vinit. 2010. “Failing to Learn? The Effects of Failure and Success on Organizational Learning in the Global Orbital Launch Vehicle Industry.” Academy of Management Journal 53:45176.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Markowitz, Harry M. 1959. Portfolio Selection: Efficient Diversification of Investments. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Google Scholar
Mazerov, Michael . 2013. Academic Research Lacks Consensus on the Impact of State Tax Cuts on Economic Growth: A Reply to the Tax Foundation. Washington, DC: Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
Google Scholar
Murray, Shelia, Ruben, Kim, Rosenberg, Carol. 2007. “State Education Spending: Current Pressures and Future Trends.” National Tax Journal 60:32545.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Perlich, Pamela S. 2000. “Demographic Trends Affecting Public Education in Utah.” Utah Business and Economic Review 60:17.
Google Scholar
Reeve, T. Ross, Perlich, Pamela S.. 2002. “The Coming Boom in Utah’s School Age and College Age Populations: State and County Scenarios.” Utah Economic and Business Review 63:16.
Google Scholar
Sheffrin, Steven M. 2004. “State Budget Deficit Dynamics and the California Debacle.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 18:20526.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Slemrod, Joel . 1990. “Optimal Taxation and Optimal Tax Systems.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 4:15778.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Sobel, Russell S., Holcombe, Randall G.. 1997. “Measuring the Growth and Variability of Tax Bases over the Business Cycle.” National Tax Journal 49:53552.
Google Scholar | ISI
Swithongrung, Arwiphawe, Kriz, Kennith A.. 2014. “The Impact of Subnational Fiscal Policies on Economic Growth: A Dynamic Analysis Approach.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 33:91228.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Syderhound, Jack . 1994. “State-local Revenue Diversification, Balance, and Fiscal Performance.” Public Finance Review 22:6882.
Google Scholar
Walker, Olene S. 2004. Recommendations on a Tax Structure for Utah’s Future. Salt Lake City, Utah: Office of the Governor.
Google Scholar
Young, Cristobal, Varner, Charles. 2011. “Millionaire Migration and State Taxation of Top Incomes: Evidence from a Natural Experiment.” National Tax Journal 64:25583.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI
Zodrow, George R. 2003. “Prospects for Consumption-based Tax Reform in the Unites States.” Finanzarchiv 59:26494.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Access content

To read the fulltext, please use one of the options below to sign in or purchase access.
  • Access Options

    My Account

    Welcome
    You do not have access to this content.

    Chinese Institutions / 中国用户

    Click the button below for the full-text content

    请点击以下获取该全文

    Institutional Login

    Purchase Content

    24 hours online access to download content

    Added to Cart

    Cart is full

    There is currently no price available for this item in your region.

    Research off-campus without worrying about access issues. Find out about Lean Library here


Purchase

PFR-article-ppv for GBP29.00
PFR-article-ppv for $37.50
Single Issue 24 hour E-access for GBP266.33
Single Issue 24 hour E-access for $319.11