Process Consent and Research with Older Persons Living with Dementia
Abstract
There is always a debate around consent in the context of research. Given the expansion of different approaches to qualitative research within dementia care, there is increasing consideration around consent in this context; particularly in research concerning the experiences of living with dementia and the care of persons with dementia. Specifically there is a drive to directly involve persons with dementia as they offer specific expertise concerning living with dementia. Additionally, capacity legislation strengthens the case for ensuring that persons with dementia are actively enabled to make their own decisions for as long as possible. This paper discusses an approach and method that can enable more persons who are living with dementia to participate in some types of research should they want to. Currently, most researchers rely on an extension of the traditional competency-based informed consent method and/or proxy consent or assent. However, related to the development of so-called person-centred and participatory research in dementia, there are now a number of academic publications on approaches and practical methods of ‘inclusionary’ consent. This paper considers the broader contextual influences on inclusionary consent and outlines the key aspects of such approaches based on the development of one specific method for including persons with dementia in consent processes. The method is based on the premise that, for persons with a dementia, informed consent becomes increasingly redundant and consequently exclusionary to them as persons. And even where capacity is said to no longer exist, persons with dementia are often able to make choices and make known their preferences about participating in research where the consent process is made specifically dementia-sensitive. Ethics committees can facilitate researchers both by supporting them when they need to and want to include persons with dementia in gerontological research and by challenging them to ensure that participation is genuine and starts with process consent.
References
1. Cutliffe J, Ramcharan P. Levelling the playing field? Exploring the merits of the ethics-as-process approach for judging qualitative research proposals. Qual Hlth Res 2002; 12(7): 1000–1010.
2. Reed J, Weiner R, Cook G. Partnership research with older people - moving towards making the rhetoric a reality. J Clin Nurs 2004; 13(s1):3–10.
3. Bravo G, Paquet M, Dubois MF. Opinions regarding who should consent to research on behalf of an older adult suffering dementia. Dementia: Int J Soc Res Pract 2003; 2(1): 49–65.
4. Gillies BA. A memory like clockwork: accounts of living through dementia. Ageing Ment Hlth 2002, 4(4): 366–374.
5. Downs M. The emergence of the person in dementia research. Aging Soc 1997; 17: 597–607.
6. Cotrell V, Schulz R. The perspective of the patient with Alzheimer's disease: a neglected dimension of dementia research. Gerontol Soc Amer 1993, 33(2): 205–211.
7. Dewing J. From ritual to relationship: a person centred approach to consent in qualitative research with older people who have a dementia. Dementia: Int J Soc Res Pract 2002; 1(2): 156–171.
8. Dewing J. Wandering into the future: reconceptualising wandering? Int J Older Peoples Nurs 2006; 1(4): 239–249.
9. Beck C, Shue V. Surrogate Decision-Making and Related Issues. Alz Dis Assoc Dis 2003; 17 suppl 1: S12–S16.
10. Vass AA, Minardi H, Ward R, Aggarwal N, Garfield C, Cybyk B. Research into communication patterns and consequences for effective care of people with Alzheimer's and their carers. Dementia: Int J Soc Res Pract 2003; 2(1): 21–48.
11. Dresser R. Missing persons: legal perceptions of incompetent patients. Rutgers Law Rev 1994; 46(92): 609–719.
12. Martin RJ, Gwther LP, Whitehouse PJ. Special care unit research: ethical issues. Alz Dis Assoc Dis 1994; 8: S360–367.
13. Post SG. The Moral Challenge of Alzheimer's disease. Baltimore:John Hopkins University, 1995.
14. Cooper MM. Reconceptualising nursing ethics. IMAGE Scholarly Inquiry for Nursing Practice 1990; 4(3): 209–221.
15. Spielman K. Demented residents rights to refuse treatment. Clinical Excellence for Nurse Practitioners 1997; 1(6): 376–381.
16. Gilhooly M. Ethical debate and developments in the law between 1984 and 2004. Generations Rev 2005; 15(1): 15–19.
17. Kitwood T. Concern for others. London:Routledge, 1990.
18. Kitwood T. Dementia reconsidered: the person comes first. Buckingham:Open University Press, 1997.
19. Wilson G. Conceptual frameworks and emancipatory research in social gerontology. Ageing Soc 2001; 21: 471–487.
20. Post SG. Alzheimer's disease and the ‘then’ self. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 1995; 5(4): 307–321.
21. Gilligan C. In a different voice: psychological theory and women's development. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1982.
22. Goldsmith M. Hearing the voices of persons with dementia: opportunities and obstacles. London:Jessica Kingsley, 1996.
23. Tappen JM, Willliams C, Fishman S, Touhy T. Persistence of self in advanced Alzheimer's disease. IMAGE Journal of Nursing Scholarship 1999; 31(2): 121–125.
24. Dworkin G. Autonomy and behaviour control. Hastings Centre Report 1976; 6(1): 23–28.
25. Bamford C, Bruce E. Defining the outcomes of community care: the perspectives of older persons with dementia and their carers. Ageing and Society 2000; 20: 543–570.
26. Mills MA. Narrative identity and dementia. A study of autobiographical memories and emotions. Aldershot:Ashgate, 1998.
27. Sabat SR. Voices of Alzheimer's disease sufferers: a call for treatment based on personhood. J Clin Ethic 1998; 9(1): 35–48.
28. Moody HR. Issues of equity in the selection of subjects for experimental research in senile dementia of the Alzheimer's type. In Melnick VL, Dubler NN (eds) Alzheimer's dilemmas and clinical research. Clifton New Jersey:Humana Press, 1985.
29. Dewing J, Pritchard E. Including the older person with a dementia in practice development. Chapter 8: in McCormack, Garbett & Manley: Perspectives on practice development in nursing. Oxford:Blackwells, 2004.
30. Sachs GA. Advance consent for dementia research. Alz Dis Assoc Dis 1994; 8 Suppl 4: 19–27.
31. Barr B, Closs J, Briggs M. Pain assessment in nursing home residents with varying degrees of cognitive impairment: frequently asked questions, 2002. At http://www.mhilli.org/dri/painfaq.htm (last accessed 13 April 2008).
32. Grout G. Negotiated consent in research. Nursing Older People 2004; 16(4): 18–20.
33. Post SG. Alzheimer's disease ethics and the progression of dementia. Clin Geriatr Med 1994; 10(2): 379–394.
34. Widdershoven GAM, Berghmans R. Advance directives in dementia care: from instructions to instruments. Patient Educ Couns 2001; 44: 179–186.
35. Pritchard EJ, Dewing J. A multi-method evaluation of an independent dementia service and its approach. Ageing Mental Hlth 2001; 5(1): 63–72.
36. Walker E, Dewar B, Dewing J, Pritchard E. An evaluation of day services from the perspectives of major stakeholders. Edinburgh:Queen Margaret's University, 2001.
37. Donnelly J. Can adults with cognitive impairment consent to take part in research. J Wound Care 2004; 13(7): 257–262.
38. Dewing J. Participatory research: a method for process consent with persons who have dementia. Dementia: Int J Soc Res Pract 2007; 6(1): 11–25.
39. McCormack B, Dewing J. (2008) The older persons services national practice development programme. At http://www.ncnm.ie/opsnpdp/index.asp (last accessed 13 April 2008).
40. Nunner-Winkler G. Two moralities? A critical discussion of an ethic of care and responsibility versus an ethic of justice and rights. In Larrabee MJ (ed) An ethic of care. Feminist and Interdisciplinary Perspectives. London:Routledge, 1993.
41. Lyman K. Living with Alzheimer's disease: the creation of meaning among persons with dementia. J Clin Ethic 1998; 9(1): 49–57.
42. Qureshi H, Bamford C, Nicholas E, Patmore C, Harris JC. Outcomes in social care practice: developing an outcome in care management and use surveys. Social Policy Research Unit, University of York, 2000.
43. Nolan M, Ryan T, Enderby P, Reid D. Towards a more inclusive vision of dementia care and research. Dementia: Int J Soc Res Pract 2002; 1(2): 193–212.
44. Botes A. Ethics of justice and ethics of care. Adv J Nurs 2002; 32(5): 1071–1075.
45. McCormack B. Researching nursing practice: does person-centredness matter? Nursing-Philosophy 2003; 4(3): 79–88.
46. Lloyd L. Mortality and morality: ageing and the ethics of care. Ageing S 2004; 24: 235–256.
47. Crisp J. Towards a partnership in maintaining personhood. Chapter 5 in Adams T, Clarke C (eds) Dementia care: developing partnerships in practice. London:Balliere Tindall, 1999.
48. Bartlett H, Martin W. Ethical issues in dementia care research. In Wilkinson H (ed). The perspectives of people with dementia: research methods and motivations. London:Jessica Kingsley, 2002.
49. Damasio A. The feeling of what happens: body emotion and the making of consciousness. London:Vintage, 2000.
50. Butterworth C. Ongoing consent to care for older people in care homes. Nurs Stand 2005; 19(20): 40–45.
51. Knight R. Interviewing people with dementia using video. J Dement Care 2005; May/June: 31–35.
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published online: July 2, 2018
Issue published: June 2008
History
Issue published: June 2008
Published online: July 2, 2018
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Article usage*
Total views and downloads: 1262
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Articles citing this one
Web of Science: 0
Crossref: 96
- Regulating the disenfranchised: Reciprocity & resistance under the Men...
- One Step at a Time: Evaluation of a Step-By-Step Recipe Tool Designed ...
- Young onset dementia: implications for employment and finances
- Just and inclusive end-of-life decision-making for long-term care home...
- Fragile storytelling: Methodological considerations when conducting et...
- Volume, scope, and consideration of ethical issues in Indigenous cogni...
- Taking time: The temporal politics of dementia, care and support in th...
- How context influences person-centred practice: a critical-creative ca...
- ‘Knocking at the door of humanity’: using co-creation and community-ba...
- Temporal Belonging: Loss of Time and Fragile Attempts to Belong with A...
- The (in)accuracies of floating leaves: How people with varying experie...
- “Acting ethically is down to you” applying ethical protocols in qualit...
- Preserving client autonomy when guiding medicine taking in telehomecar...
- Psychodrama with persons with dementia on zoom: Proof of concept
- Enhancing engagement in meaningful occupation in a dementia town: A qu...
- A qualitative exploration of living with dementia in supported living ...
- An intergenerational playgroup in an Australian residential aged‐care ...
- Music‐making in the community with people living with dementia and car...
- ‘Guid times wi the bad times’: The meanings and experiences of befrien...
- Power, Authority, and Voice
- A Multiple Stakeholder Perspective on the Impact of COVID-19 on Dement...
- Development of a Home-Based Stress Management Toolkit for Dementia Car...
- In Their Own Words: How COVID-19 Has Impacted the Well-Being of Person...
- Self-reported benefits for care partners of attending a person-centred...
- “It's just so important that people's voices are heard”: The dementia ...
- Remembering the past, enhancing the present and sharing the future: a ...
- Older adult and family caregiver preferences for emergency department ...
- Moments of meaning: Enacted narratives of occupational engagement with...
- Partnering with older people as peer researchers
- “You’re Part of Us and We’re Happy to Have You Here”: Practices of Soc...
- Health promotion initiative: A dementia-friendly local community in Sw...
- ‘You come because it is an interesting place’: The impact of attending...
- People living with dementia and their family carers’ adherence to home...
- The importance of living well now and relationships: A qualitative stu...
- Development of an ethical roadmap
- Missed Nursing Care Among Patients With Dementia During Hospitalizatio...
- How nurses can support the inclusion in research of older people who l...
- Beyond the shrinking world: dementia, localisation and neighbourhood
- ‘It's our pleasure, we count cars here’: an exploration of the ‘neighb...
- Experiences of rural life among community-dwelling older men with deme...
- Patient and informal carer experience of hip fracture: a qualitative s...
- Intensive home care supports, informal care and private provision for ...
- ‘Unlocking the door to being there’: The contribution of creative faci...
- Co-creating Design Opportunities for Social Technology in the Context ...
- Nurses’ provisions for self-determination in residents with cognitive ...
- Developing a Management Guide (the DemPower App) for Couples Where One...
- Power, Authority, and Voice
- Exploring the Effects of a Golf Program on Psychological and Social We...
- Focusing on Emotional and Social Intelligence Stimulation of People Wi...
- An under-represented and underserved population in trials: methodologi...
- Test-retest reliability of the short version of the everyday technolog...
- Exploring the ‘active mechanisms’ for engaging rural-dwelling older me...
- The perceived and observed needs of patients with dementia admitted to...
- The Impact of Implementing a Namaste Care Intervention in UK Care Home...
- Couples’ experiences of using DemPower in everyday life
- Older people's perspectives on living in integrated housing and care s...
- Ethical and legal aspects of research involving older people with cogn...
- Adherence to the Class-Based Component of a Tai Chi Exercise Intervent...
- Beyond Façade: Home Making and Truthfulness in Dementia Care
- A systematic review of electronic assistive technology within supporti...
- Hospital nurse staffing and staff–patient interactions: an observation...
- Effectively including the voice of residents in care home design
- Relational ethics in palliative care research: including a ...
- Support Needs and Expectations of People Living with Dementia and Thei...
- Acceptability of a Dyadic Tai Chi Intervention for Older People Living...
- ‘Well I’m still the Diva!’ Enabling people with dementia to express th...
- Partizipation von Menschen mit Demenz fördert ihre Gesundheit
- Researching with People with Dementia
- Using longitudinal qualitative research to explore extra care housing
- Intensive home care packages for people with dementia: a realist evalu...
- Participation in a trial in the emergency situation: a qualitative stu...
- Negative-pressure wound therapy versus standard dressings for adults w...
- Consent recommendations for research and international data sharing in...
- Living Life and Doing Things Together: Collaborative Research With Cou...
- Implementing the Creating Learning Environments for Compassionate Care...
- Involving people with dementia in developing an interactive web tool f...
- Art, music, story: The evaluation of a person-centred arts in health p...
- Review: Evaluating the effects of a physical activity on agitation and...
- Developing best practice guidelines for designing living environments ...
- Designing and Implementing a Home-Based Couple Management Guide for Co...
- The development of service user-led recommendations for health and soc...
- Understanding patient and relative/carer experience of hip fracture in...
- Using Experience-based Co-design with older patients, their families a...
- Researching with People with Dementia
- Reflections on the Use of Visual Methods in a Qualitative Study of Dom...
- Confidentiality in participatory research: Challenges from one study
- What is the current state of care for older people with dementia in ge...
- Does Digital Gaming Enable Healthy Aging for Community-Dwelling People...
- A Novel Visual Method for Studying Complex Health Transitions for Olde...
- References
- Advance directives in dementia research: The opinions and arguments of...
- People with dementia and the hospital environment: the view of patient...
- References
- Actively involving people with dementia in qualitative research
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
View options
PDF/ePub
View PDF/ePubGet access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
