![[PDF]](/pb-assets/Icons/adobe-pdf-icon-1498649896243.png){kind=icon}
Abstract
A review of 39 studies indicated that achievement test scores decline over summer vacation. The results of the 13 most recent studies were combined using meta-analytic procedures. The meta-analysis indicated that the summer loss equaled about one month on a grade-level equivalent scale, or one tenth of a standard deviation relative to spring test scores. The effect of summer break was more detrimental for math than for reading and most detrimental for math computation and spelling. Also, middle-class students appeared to gain on grade-level equivalent reading recognition tests over summer while lower-class students lost on them. There were no moderating effects for student gender or race, but the negative effect of summer did increase with increases in students’ grade levels. Suggested explanations for the findings include the differential availability of opportunities to practice different academic material over summer (with reading practice more available than math practice) and differences in the material’s susceptibility to memory decay (with fact- and procedure-based knowledge more easily forgotten than conceptual knowledge). The income differences also may be related to differences in opportunities to practice and learn. The results are examined for implications concerning summer school programs and proposals concerning school calendar changes
References
| Allinder, RM, Fuchs, LS, Fuchs, D, Hamlett, CL Effects of summer break on math and spelling performance as a function of grade levelThe Elementary School Journal199292451460 Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI | |
| Arnold, RD Retention in reading of disadvantaged Mexican-American children during the summer months1968AprilPaper presented at the meeting of the International Reading AssociationBoston, MA Google Scholar | |
| Association of California School Administrators A primer on year-round education1988Sacramento, CAAuthor Google Scholar | |
| Ballinger, CE, Kirschenbaum, N, Poimbeauf, RP The year-round school-Where learning never stops1987Bloomington, INPhi Delta Kappa Google Scholar | |
| Barrett, MJ The case for more school daysAtlantic Monthly199026678106 Google Scholar | |
| Beggs, DL, Hieronymus, AN Uniformity of growth in the basic skills throughout the school year and during the summerJournal of Educational Measurement196859197 Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI | |
| Bender, JF Retention of experience by school childrenProceedings of the Oklahoma Academy of Science1944255961 Google Scholar | |
| Botwin, JR Summer and school year correlates of academic achievement1965Cleveland, OHCase Western Reserve UniversityUnpublished doctoral dissertation Google Scholar | |
| Brueckner, LJ, Distad, HW The effect of the summer vacation on the reading ability of first-grade childrenThe Elementary School Journal192424698707 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Bruene, E Effect of the summer vacation on the achievement of pupils in the fourth, fifth, and sixth gradesJournal of Educational Research192818309314 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Bryk, AS, Raudenbush, SW Toward a more appropriate conceptualization of research on school effects: A three-level hierarchical linear modelAmerican Journal of Education19889765108 Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI | |
| Carter, LF The sustaining effects study of compensatory and elementary educationEducational Researcher1984137413 Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | |
| Cohen, J Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences19882nd edHillsdale, NJErlbaum Google Scholar | |
| Cook, RC Vacation retention of fundamentals by primary-grade pupilsThe Elementary School Journal194243214219 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Cooper, G, Sweller, J Effects of schema acquisition and rule automation on mathematical problem-solving transferJournal of Education Psychology198779347362 Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI | |
| Cooper, H, Hedges, LV The handbook of research synthesis1994New YorkRussell Sage Foundation Google Scholar | |
| Cooper, H Integrating research: A guide for literature reviews1989Newbury Park, CASage Google Scholar | |
| Davis, RA, Rood, EJ Remembering and forgetting arithmetical abilitiesThe Journal of Educational Psychology194738216222 Google Scholar | Crossref | Medline | |
| Elam, SM, Rose, LC, Gallop, AM The 28th annual Phi Delta Kappa/ Gallop poll of the public’s attitudes toward the public schoolsPhi Delta Kappan1996784159 Google Scholar | ISI | |
| Elder, HE The effect of the summer vacation on silent-reading ability in the intermediate gradesThe Elementary School Journal192727541546 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Entwistle, DR, Alexander, KL Summer setback: Race, poverty, school composition, and mathematics achievement in the first two years of schoolAmerican Sociological Review1992577284 Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI | |
| Entwistle, DR, Alexander, KL Winter setback: The racial composition of schools and learning to readAmerican Sociological Review199459446460 Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI | |
| Fitzsimmons, ME Analytical study of the retention of selected skills1969Bronx, NYFordham UniversityUnpublished doctoral dissertation Google Scholar | |
| Gandara, P, Fish, J Year-round schooling as an avenue to major structural reformEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis1994166785 Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Garfinkel, MA The effect of the summer vacation on ability in the fundamentals of arithmeticThe Journal of Educational Psychology1919104448 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Gastright, JF Summer loss in reading achievement: A comparison of fall to spring reading achievement gains with fall to fall reading achievement gains1979SeptemberPaper presented at the annual meeting of the Evaluation NetworkCincinnati, OH Google Scholar | |
| Geary, DC Reflections of evolution and culture in children’s cognitionAmerican Psychologist1995502437 Google Scholar | Crossref | Medline | ISI | |
| Ginsburg, A, Baker, K, Sweet, D, Rosenthal, A Summer learning and the effects of schooling: A replication of Heyns1981AprilPaper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research AssociationLos Angeles, CA Google Scholar | |
| Glass, AL, Holyoak, KJ Cognition1986New YorkRandom House Google Scholar | |
| Grenier, MA An investigation of summer mathematics achievement loss and the fall recovery timeDissertation Abstracts International1975363069A(Doctoral dissertation, University of Georgia, 1975) Google Scholar | |
| Hawn, HC, Ellett, CD, Des Jardines, L Differences in mathematics achievement between males and females in Grades 1–31981MarchPaper presented at the annual meeting of the Eastern Educational Research AssociationPhiladelphia, PA Google Scholar | |
| Hayes, DP, Grether, J The school year and vacations: When do students learn?1969AprilPaper presented at the meeting of the Eastern Sociological AssociationNew York Google Scholar | |
| Hedges, LV, Olkin, I Statistical methods for meta-analysis1985New YorkAcademic Press Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Heyns, B Summer learning and the effects of schooling1978New YorkAcademic Press Google Scholar | |
| Heyns, B Schooling and cognitive development: Is there as season for learningChild Development19875811511160 Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI | |
| Houston, JP Fundamentals of learning and memory1991San Diego, CAHarcourt Brace Jovanovich Google Scholar | |
| Irmina, SM The effects of summer vacation upon the retention of the elementary school subjectsEducational Research Bulletins1928399 Google Scholar | |
| Jamar, I Fall testing: Are some students differentially disadvantaged?1994Pittsburgh, PAUniversity of Pittsburgh, Learning Research and Development Center Google Scholar | |
| Johns, JL, Vacca, RT An inquiry into summer loss in reading: Grades 1–7Reading Horizons198424208215 Google Scholar | |
| Karweit, N Should we lengthen the school year?Educational Researcher1985746915 Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | |
| Katsiyannis, A Extended school year policies: An established necessityRemedial and Special Education1991122428 Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Keys, N, Lawson, JV Summer versus winter gains in school achievementSchool and Society193746541544 Google Scholar | |
| Klibanoff, LS, Haggart, SA Summer growth and the effectiveness of summer school1981Mountain View, CARMC Research Corporation(Rep. No. 8) Google Scholar | |
| Kolberg, OW A study of summer-time forgettingThe Elementary School Journal193435281287 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Kramer, GA Do children forget during the vacation?Baltimore Bulletin of Education192765660 Google Scholar | |
| Lahey, MF Permanence of retention of first-year algebraThe Journal of Educational Psychology194132401413 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Mazzarella, JA Longer day, longer year: Will they make a difference?Principal1984631420 Google Scholar | |
| McCormick, C, Mason, JM What happens to kindergarten children’s knowledge about reading after a summer vacation?The Reading Teacher198135164172 Google Scholar | ISI | |
| Merino, BJ The impact of year-round schooling: A reviewUrban Education198318298316 Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Morgan, LD How effective is specific training in preventing loss due to the summer vacation?The Journal of Educational Psychology192920466471 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Mousley, W Testing the ‘summer learning loss’ argumentPhi Delta Kappan197354705 Google Scholar | |
| Murname, R The impact of school resources on inner-city school children1975Cambridge, MABallenger Google Scholar | |
| National Education Commission on Time and Learning Prisoners of time1994Washington, DCU.S. Government Printing Office Google Scholar | |
| National Institute of Education Compensatory education study1978Washington, DCU.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare Google Scholar | |
| Nelson, MJ How much time is required in the fall for pupils of the elementary school to reach again the spring level of achievement?Journal of Educational Research192818305308 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Noonan, ME Influence of the summer vacation on the abilities of fifth and sixth grade childrenContributions to Education1926204103 Google Scholar | |
| Parsley, KM, Powell, M Achievement gains or losses during the academic year and over the summer vacation period: A study of trends in achievement by sex and grade level among students of average intelligenceGenetic Psychology Monographs196266285342 Google Scholar | Medline | |
| Patterson, MV, Rensselaer, NY The effect of the summer vacation on children’s mental ability and on their retention of arithmetic and readingEducation192546222228 Google Scholar | |
| Pelavin, SH, David, JL Evaluating long-term achievement: An analysis of longitudinal data from compensatory education programs1977Washington, DCEducational Policy Research Center(SRI Project No. 4537) Google Scholar | |
| Sardo-Brown, D, Rooney, M The vote on all-year schoolsAmerican School Board Journal19921792527 Google Scholar | |
| Sargent, LR, Fidler, DA Extended school year programs: In support of the conceptEducation and Training in Mental Retardation19872239 Google Scholar | |
| SAS Institute SAS user’s guide: Statistics (Version 5)1985Cary, NCAuthor Google Scholar | |
| Schrepel, M, Laslett, HR On the loss of knowledge by junior high-school pupils over the summer vacationThe Journal of Educational Psychology193627299303 Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Scott, LF Summer loss in modern and traditional elementary school mathematics programsCalifornia Journal of Educational Research196718145151 Google Scholar | ISI | |
| Shaw, VT Retention of selected reading and arithmetic skills by learning disabled pupils and non-disabled pupils over summer vacation1982StanislausCalifornia State CollegeUnpublished master’s thesis Google Scholar | |
| Soar, RS, Soar, RM Pupil subject matter growth during summer vacationEducational Leadership19692577587 Google Scholar | |
| White, WF Reviews before and after vacationAmerican Education190610185188 Google Scholar | |
| Wintre, MG Challenging the assumption of generalized academic losses over summerJournal of Educational Research198679308312 Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI |
