Open access

Research article

First published March 2004

Request permissions

Back to the Land: The Paradox of Organic Food Standards

Julie Guthman [email protected]View all authors and affiliations

Volume 36, Issue 3

https://doi.org/10.1068/a36104

Abstract
References

Abstract

This paper examines how the rent-creating conventions that regulate organic food production undermine growers' abilities to farm in a less intensive manner. The paper builds on a growing literature on food governance which points to the unintended consequences of standardization and their verification. The argument is based in theories of rent, with specific attention to how the constructed scarcity of organic food creates rents that are competed away or appropriated. The author also discusses how organic regulations may manifest in monopoly ground rents, especially given the attention paid to land in organic certification. Insofar as these rents pass through to land values, they contribute to a broader pattern of land valuation that pushes farmers to grow the most valuable crops in the most productive ways—an imperative that is not necessarily conducive to organic farming as it is generally envisioned.

References

Agriculture Research Service, 1958, “Current developments in the farm real estate market: November 1957–March 1958”, US Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC

Arce A, Marsden T, 1994, “The social construction of international food: A new research agenda” Economic Geography 69 293–311

Baker L, 2002, “The not-so-sweet success of organic farming”, http://www.salon.com/tech/feature/2002/07/29/organic/index.html?x

Ball M, 1980, “On Marx's theory of agricultural rent—a reply to Ben Fine” Economy and Society 9 304–326

Barham B, Bunker S G, O'Hearn D, 1994 States, Firms and Raw Materials: The World Economy and Ecology of Aluminium (University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI)

Beardsworth A, Keil T, 1997 Sociology on the Menu (Routledge, London)

Bell D, Valentine G, 1997 Consuming Geographies: We Are Where We Eat (Routledge, London)

Blank S C, 2000, “Some facts about farmland values” Agriculture and Resource Economics Update 3 (Summer) 3–4

Bocock R, 1993 Consumption (Routledge, London)

Buck D, Getz C, Guthman J, 1996, “Consolidating the commodity chain: Organic farming and agribusiness in northern California”, Development Report 11, Institute for Food and Development Policy, Oakland, CA

Buck D, Getz C, Guthman J, 1997, “From farm to table: The organic vegetable commodity chain of northern California” Sociologia Ruralis 37 3–20

Burnham T J, 2000, “Liquid assets” California Farmer, 29–30 November, pages 32, 34, 36, 38

Busch L, 1997, “Grades and standards in the social construction of safe food”, paper presented at The Social Construction of Safe Food, Norwegian Technical University, Trondheim, http://www.msu.edu/user/ifas/papers.html

Busch L, 2000, “The moral economy of grades and standards” Journal of Rural Studies 16 273–283

Cal ASFMARA, 2000, “Land and lease values”, http://www.calasfmra.com/landvalues/2000/

California Organic Foods Act, 1990 Cal ALS 1262; 1990 Cal AB 2012; Stat 1990 chapter 1262

Clunies-Ross T, Cox G, 1994, “Challenging the productivist paradigm: Organic farming and the politics of agricultural change”, in Regulating Agriculture Eds Lowe P, Marsden T, Whatmore S (David Fulton, London) pp 53–74

Cochrane W W, 1993 The Development of American Agriculture (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)

Cook I, Crang P, 1996, “The world on a plate: Culinary culture, displacement and geographical knowledges” Journal of Material Culture 1 131–154

Daniels T, Bowers D, 1997 Holding Our Ground: Protecting America's Farms and Farmland (Island Press, Washington, DC)

DeLind L B, 1993, “Market niches, ‘cul de sacs’, and social context: Alternative systems of food production” Culture and Agriculture 47 7–12

Dunn E, 2003, “Trojan pig: Paradoxes of food safety regulation” Environment and Planning A 35 1493–1511

Economic Research Service, 2000, “Farm real estate values”, Statistical Bulletin, 855, http://www.ers.usda.gov

Esbenshade J, 2001 The Social Accountability Contract: Private Monitoring and Labor Relations in the Global Apparel Industry PhD dissertation, Ethnic Studies, University of California, Berkeley, CA

Fine B, 1979, “On Marx's theory of agricultural rent” Economy and Society 8 241–278

Fine B, 1994, “Towards a political economy of food” Review of International Political Economy 1 519–545

Fine B, Leopold E, 1994 The World of Consumption (Routledge, London)

FitzSimmons M, 1986, “The new industrial agriculture” Economic Geography 62 334–353

Freidberg S, 2003a, “Cleaning up down south: Supermarkets, ethical trade, and African horticulture” Journal of Social and Cultural Geography 4 27–42

Freidberg S, 2003b, “Culture, conventions and colonial constructions of rurality in south-north horticultural trade” Journal of Rural Studies 19 97–109

Goodman M, 1999, “Developmental consumption: Embedding relationships of the international organic food commodity”, paper presented at Conventional and Organic Agriculture—Encounters at the Interface, University of California, Santa Cruz, CA; copy available from the author, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA

Goodman D, Redclift M, 1991 Refashioning Nature (Routledge, London)

Goodman D, Watts M, 1994, “Reconfiguring the rural or fording the divide” Journal of Peasant Studies 221 1–49

Goodman D, Sorj B, Wilkinson J, 1987 From Farming to Biotechnology (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)

Gouveia L, Juska A, 2002, “Taming nature, taming workers: Constructing the separation between meat consumption and meat production in the US” Sociologia Ruralis 42 370–390

Guthman J, 1998, “Regulating meaning, appropriating nature: The codification of California organic agriculture” Antipode 30 135–54

Guthman J, 2000, “Raising organic: An agro-ecological assessment of grower practices in California” Agriculture and Human Values 17 257–266

Guthman J, 2003a, “Fast food/organic food: Reflexive tastes and the making of ‘yuppie chow’” Journal of Social and Cultural Geography 4 43–56

Guthman J, 2003b, “Eating risk: The politics of labeling transgenic foods”, in Remaking the World: Genetic Engineering and Its Discontents, Eds Schurman R, Takahashi-Kelso D (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 130–151

Guthman J, 2004, “The ‘organic commodity’ and other anomalies in the politics of consumption”, in Geographies of Commodity Chains Eds Hughes A, Reimer S (Routledge, London) forthcoming

Hart P, 2003, “Hitting the organic jackpot by making shopping a state of mind, the whole foods market chain has become a giant among natural-foods retailers” Boston Globe 16 March, page 10

Harvey D, 1982 Limits to Capital (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)

Harvey D, 2001 Spaces of Capital (Routledge, New York)

Haug W, 1986 Critique of Commodity Aesthetics: Appearance, Sexuality and Advertising in Capitalist Society (Polity Press, Cambridge)

Jaffee S, 1994, “Exporting high-value commodities”, DP 198, World Bank, Washington, DC

Kaplinsky R, 2000, “Globalization and unequalisation: What can be learned from value chain analysis?” Journal of Development Studies 37 117–146

Korsmeyer C, 1999 Making Sense of Taste: Food and Philosophy (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)

Lampkin N, Padel S (Eds), 1994 The Economics of Organic Farming (CAB International, Wallingford, Oxon)

Michelsen J, 2001, “Recent development and political acceptance of organic farming in Europe” Sociologia Ruralis 41 3–20

Morgan K, Murdoch J, 2000, “Organic vs. conventional agriculture: Knowledge, power and innovation in the food chain” Geoforum 31 159–173

Mutersbaugh T, 2002, “The number is the beast: A political economy of organic-coffee certification and producer unionism” Environment and Planning A 34 1165–1184

National Organic Program, 2001, “Definitions—regulatory text”, http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standards/DefineReg.html

Organic Foods Production Act, 1990, P.L. 101–624, title XXI, $2102, 104 Stat 3935, short title 7USC §§6501 et seq

Pollan M, 2001 The Botany of Desire (Random House, New York)

Pressly T J, Scofield W H (Eds), 1965 Farm Real Estate Values in the United States by Counties, 1850–1959 (University of Washington Press, Seattle, MA)

Raynolds L, 2002, “Consumer-producer links in Fair Trade coffee networks” Sociologia Ruralis 42 404–424

Rosset P M, Altieri M, 1997, “Agroecology versus input substitution: A fundamental contradiction of sustainable agriculture” Society and Natural Resources 10 283–295

Sayer A, 1997, “The dialectic of culture and economy”, in Geographies of Economies Eds Lee R, Wills J (Arnold, London) pp 16–26

Schumpeter J, 1939 Business Cycles (McGraw-Hill, New York)

Shoemaker R, 1989, “Long run determinants of land values”, Situation and Outlook Report, Agricultural Resources, Agricultural Land Values and Markets Economics Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC

Strange M, 1988 Family Farming: A New Economic Vision (University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, NE)

Sylvander B, 1995, “Conventions de qualité, concurrence, et coopération: Cas du ‘label rouge’ dans la filière volailles” [Conventions of quality, competition, and cooperation: The case of the ‘red label’ in the poultry commodity chain], in La Grande Transformation de l'Agriculture: Lectures Conventionalistes et Régulationistes Eds Allaire G, Boyer R (Economica, Paris) pp 73–96

Thevenot L, 1998, “Innovating in ‘qualified’ markets: Quality, norms, and conventions”, paper presented at Workshop on Systems and Trajectories of Agricultural Innovation, Institute of International Studies, University of California, Berkeley, CA; copy available from the author, École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales, Paris

Walker R, 1974, “Urban ground rent: Building a new conceptual framework” Antipode 6 51–59

Wells M, 1996 Strawberry Fields: Politics, Class, and Work in California Agriculture (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)

Whatmore S, Thorne L, 1997, “Nourishing networks: Alternative geographies of food”, in Globalising Food: Agrarian Questions and Global Restructuring Eds Goodman D, Watts M J (Routledge, London) pp 287–304