Creating Modern Chinese Metaphysics: Feng Youlan and New Realism
Abstract
Feng Youlan (1895–1990), a preeminent philosopher of twentieth-century China, tried to build a modern Chinese metaphysics that was at once universal and based on a structure of traditional Chinese concepts such as li/principles and qi/vital energy. His intellectual borrowings included New Realism, an early twentieth-century school of philosophy that attempted to provide a scientific basis for metaphysics. New Realism’s affirmation of the objectivity of a priori logical relationships in the universe enabled Feng to construct a metaphysical structure of philosophy in China without becoming bogged down in the debate of the priority of practice over principle in Chinese history. While most published work has treated Feng’s famous “negative method” as the “more Chinese” part of his work in contrast to his writings influenced by New Realism, this article argues that Feng’s logical/metaphysical construct of philosophy in China sought to build a metaphysical discourse of experience by employing both a logical/analytical and a “negative” nonverbal method resembling Chan Buddhist practices.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
Azuma Juji (1993) “Xinlixue de xingcheng: Feng Youlan he xinshizailun” (The formation of new rationalism: Feng Youlan and the influence of New Realism). Pp. 237–40 in Daisun Chen, et al . (eds.), Feng Youlan xiansheng jinian wenji (Commemorative collection on Feng Youlan). Beijing: Beijing daxue chubanshe.
Azuma Juji (1994) “The formation of New Lixue—Feng Youlan and New Realism.” Pp. 303–36 in Obenchain, 1994.
Beijing daxue zhexuexi jianshi (1914–1994) [A brief history of the Department of Philosophy at Peking University, 1914–1994] (1994) Beijing: Beijing daxue zhexuexi.
Cai Zhongde (1997) Feng Youlan yanjiu (Studies on Feng Youlan), vol. 1. Beijing: Guoji wenhua chuban gongsi.
Chen Derong (2011) Metaphorical Metaphysics in Chinese Philosophy: Illustrated with Feng Youlan’s New Metaphysics. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
Chen Lai(2006a) Chuantong yu xiandai renwenzhuyi de shiye (Tradition and the present: a humanist’s view). Beijing: Beijing daxue chubanshe.
Chen Lai(2006b) “Feng Youlan wenhuaguan de jianli yu fazhan” (How Feng Youlan established and developed his views on culture). Pp. 130–62 in Chen Lai, 2006a.
Chen Lai(2006c) “Liang Shuming zaoqi de dongxi wenhuaguan” (Liang Shuming’s early views on Eastern and Western cultures). Pp. 97–129 in Chen Lai, 2006a.
Chen Zhanguo (2002) “Feng Youlan xiansheng de xingshangxue” (Mr. Feng Youlan’s metaphysics). Pp. 343–63 in Zheng Jiadong and Chen Peng, 2002.
De Bary Wm. Theodore. (2000) Sources of Chinese Tradition, vol. 1. New York: Columbia Univ. Press.
Defoort Carine (2006) “Is ‘Chinese philosophy’ a proper name? A response to Rein Raud.” Philosophy East & West 56, 4: 625–60.
De Waal Cornelis (2001a) “Introduction.” Vol. 1, pp. xiii–xxxv in de Waal, 2001b.
De Waal Cornelis (2001b) American New Realism, 1910–1920. 3 vols. Bristol, England: Thoemmes.
Feng Youlan (1926) “Renshengzhexue zhi bijiaoyanjiu xuyan” (Preface to a comparative study of life ideals). Vol. 1, pp. 575–84 in Feng Youlan, 1985–1994.
Feng Youlan (1927) “Mengtegu lun gongxiang” (Montague on universals). Trans. from Montague W. P. The Ways of Knowing (London: George Allen & Unwin; New York: Macmillan, 1925), 69–78, 107–112. Vol. 11, pp. 168–78 in Feng Youlan, 1985–1994.
Feng Youlan (1931) Zhongguo zhexueshi (A history of Chinese philosophy), vol. 1. Vol. 2, pp. 3–372 in Feng Youlan, 1985–1994.
Feng Youlan ([1934] 1984) “Zhongguo xiandai zhexue” (Contemporary Chinese philosophy). In Feng Youlan, Sansongtang xueshuwenji (Collected essays of the owner of the house of three pines). Beijing: Beijing renmin daxue chubanshe.
Feng Youlan (1938) Xinlixue (New philosophy of principle). Vol 4, pp. 3–214 in Feng Youlan, 1985–1994.
Feng Youlan (1939) Xinshilun (A new treatise on practical affairs). Vol. 4, pp. 217–365 in Feng Youlan, 1985–1994.
Feng Youlan (1940) Xinshixun (A new treatise on the way of life). Vol. 4, pp. 368–510 in Feng Youlan, 1985–1994.
Feng Youlan (1942) Xinyuanren (A new treatise on the nature of man). Vol. 4, pp. 511–697 in Feng Youlan, 1985–1994.
Feng Youlan (1946) Xinzhiyan (A new understanding of words). Vol. 5, pp. 163–270 in Feng Youlan, 1985–1994.
Feng Youlan (1948) “Chinese philosophy and a future of world philosophy.” Philosophical Rev. 57, 6: 539–49.
Feng Youlan (1981) ““Zhang Zai de zhexuesixiang jiqi zai daoxuezhong de diwei” (Zhang Zai’s philosophical thinking and his position in Daoism). Vol. 13, pp. 356–86 in Feng Youlan, 1985–1994.
Feng Youlan (1985–1994) Sansongtang quanji (Complete collection of the owner of the house of three pines). 13 vols. Youguang Tu, ed. Kaifeng: Henan renmin chubanshe.
Furth Charlotte (1970) Ting Wen-chiang: Science and China’s New Culture. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.
Gore Willard (1914) “Externality and inhibition.” Vol. 3, pp. 147–52 in de Waal, 2001b.
Guo Qiyong (2002) “Xingshi chouxiang de zhexue yu rensheng yijing de zhexue” (Formally abstract philosophy and philosophy concerning states of being). Pp. 327–42 in Zheng Jiadong and Chen Peng, 2002.
Hollands Edmund H. (1914) “The externality of relations.” Vol. 3, pp. 159–66 in de Waal, 2001b.
Holt Edwin B., Marvin Walter T., Montague William Pepperrell, Perry Ralph Baerton, Pitkin Walter B., Spaulding Edward Gleason (1910) “The program and first platform of six realists.” J. of Philosophy, Psychology, and Scientific Methods 7, 15: 393–401.
Holt Edwin B., Marvin Walter T., Montague William Pepperrell, Perry Ralph Baerton, Pitkin Walter B., Spaulding Edward Gleason (1912) The New Realism: Cooperative Studies in Philosophy. New York: Macmillan.
Hu Jun (1997) “Feng Youlan xinlixue fangfalun pipan” (A critique of the methodology of Feng Youlan’s New Philosophy of Principle). Pp. 156–70 in Cai Zhongde, 1997.
Hu Weixi (2005) Zhuan shi cheng zhi, Qinghua xuepai yu ershi shiji Zhongguo zhexue (Transforming knowledge into wisdom: the Tsinghua school and twentieth-century Chinese philosophy). Shanghai: Huadong shifan daxue chubanshe.
Kant Immanuel (1950) Critique of Pure Reason. Tr. Smith Norman Kemp. New York: Humanities Press.
Kurtz Joachim (2004) “Matching names and actualities: translation and the discovery of Chinese logic.” Pp. 471–505 in Lackner Michael, Vittinghoff Natascha (eds.), Mapping Meanings: The Field of New Learning in Late Qing China. Leiden: Brill.
Lin Xiaoqing Diana (2005) Peking University, Chinese Intellectuals and Scholarship, 1898–1937. Albany: State Univ. of New York Press.
Lin Xiaoqing Diana (2012) “Developing the academic discipline of Chinese philosophy: the departments of philosophy at Peking, Tsinghua, and Yenching Universities (1910s–30s).” Pp. 131–61 in Makeham, 2012a.
Lovejoy Arthur (1911) “Reflections of a temporalist on the new realism.” Vol. 1, pp. 187–97 in de Waal, 2001b.
Lovejoy Arthur (1913a) “Error and the new realism.” Vol. 2, pp. 215–16 in de Waal, 2001b.
Lovejoy Arthur (1913b) “Realism versus epistemological monism.” Vol. 3, pp. 35–46 in de Waal, 2001b.
Makeham John [ed.] (2012a) Learning to Emulate the Wise: The Genesis of Chinese Philosophy as an Academic Discipline in Twentieth-Century China. Hong Kong: Chinese Univ. Press.
Makeham John (2012b) “The role of masters studies in the early formation of Chinese philosophy as an academic discipline.” Pp. 73–101 in Makeham, 2012a.
Makeham John (2012c) “Introduction.” Pp. 1–35 in Makeham, 2012a.
Mao Mingjia (2004) Huanyuan Feng Youlan (Recovering the true Feng Youlan). Hong Kong: Tianma chuban youxian gongsi.
Masson Michel (1985) Philosophy and Tradition: The Interpretation of China’s Philosophic Past: Fung Yu-lan 1939–1949. Taipei: Ricci Institute.
Moeller Hans-Georg (2000) Die philosophischste Philosophie. Feng Youlans Neue Metaphysik. Mit einer Übersetzung der Neuen Methodologie. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz.
Moeller Hans-Georg (2012) “Daoism as academic philosophy: Feng Youlan’s New Metaphysics (Xin Lixue).” Pp. 217–35 in Makeham, 2012a.
Moore Addison (1913) “The aviary theory of truth and error.” Vol. 3, pp. 23–27 in de Waal, 2001b.
Obenchain Diane [ed.] (1994) “Something exists: selected papers on the thought of Feng Youlan.” J. of Chinese Philosophy, 21, 3/4.
Perry Ralph Barton (1912) “A realistic theory of independence.” Pp. 99–154 in Holt et al., 1912.
Perry Ralph (1913) “Some disputed points in neo-realism.” Vol. 3, pp. 1–15 in de Waal, 2001b.
Pfister Lauren (2002) “Feng Youlan’s New Principle Learning and his histories of Chinese philosophy.” Pp. 165–87 in Cheng Chung-Ying, Bunnin Nick (eds.), Contemporary Chinese Philosophy. Oxford: Blackwell.
Pomerleau Wayne (1997) Twelve Great Philosophers: A Historical Introduction to Human Nature. Lanham, MD: Ardsley House.
Pratt James (1912) “Professor Perry’s proofs of realism.” J. Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific Methods 9, 21: 573–80.
Russell Bertrand ([1912] 2007) Problems of Philosophy. New York: Cosimo.
Tang Yanfang (1999) “Language, truth, and literary interpretation: a cross-cultural examination.” J. of the History of Ideas 60, 1: 1–20.
Yang Guorong (2002) “Rensheng jingjieshuo, xinlixue de luoji zhongdian” (The theory of intellectual/spiritual realms in human life as the ultimate end of the logic in New Philosophy of Principle). Pp. 364–78 in Zheng Jiadong and Chen Peng, 2002.
Yin Lujun (1994) “From Montague to Neo-Confucianism: Feng Youlan’s ‘New Lixue’ and logical analysis.” Pp. 337–62 in Obenchain, 1994.
Yip Wai-Lim (1993) Diffusion of Distances: Dialogues between Chinese and Western Poetics. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.
Zheng Jiadong(2004) “Zhongguo zhexueshi xiezuo yu Zhongguo sixiang chuantong de xiandai kunjing” (The writing of the history of Chinese philosophy and the modern dilemma of the Chinese intellectual tradition). Zhongguo renmin daxue xuebao 3: 2–11.
Zheng Jiadong, Peng Chen (2002) Jiexi Feng Youlan (An analysis of Feng Youlan). Beijing: Shehui kexue wenxian chubanshe.
Biographies
Xiaoqing Diana Lin is an associate professor of history at Indiana University Northwest. She is completing an intellectual biography of Feng Youlan.
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published online: March 21, 2013
Issue published: January 2014
Keywords
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Article usage*
Total views and downloads: 247
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 3 view articles Opens in new tab
Crossref: 5
- Intellectual Development and Mathematics Learning
- Dao Companion to Contemporary Confucian Philosophy
- Le dilemme d’une métaphysique chinoise
- Pan-Asian Poetics: Tagore and the Interpersonal in May Fourth New Poetry
- Feng Youlan and Dialectical/Historical Materialism, 1930s–1950s
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
I am signed in as:
View my profileSign out
I can access personal subscriptions, purchases, paired institutional access and free tools such as favourite journals, email alerts and saved searches.
loading institutional access options
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
