![[PDF]](/pb-assets/Icons/adobe-pdf-icon-1498649896243.png){kind=icon}
Abstract
In Portugal, public and political discussions about same-sex marriage have been going on since the 1990s. In 2010, same-sex marriage was legalized under intense dispute since it excludes same-sex couples from adoption and reproductive rights. During parliamentary debates, political parties and civil organizations linked to the Catholic Church resorted to conflicting ideas of ‘equality’ and ‘difference’ to advance their claims. In this article, we analyse the contents of petitions, bills and parliamentary proceedings concerning the legal recognition of same-sex unions, highlighting the presence of conflicting notions of equality linked to pervasive beliefs about the inadequacy of homo-erotic desire and practices.
Keywords Equality, parliamentary debates, Portugal, rights, same-sex marriage
References
| Almeida, MV (2006) O casamento entre pessoas do mesmo sexo. Revista Crítica de Ciências Sociais 76: 17–31. Google Scholar | |
| Almeida, MV (2009) A Chave do Armário: Homossexualidade, casamento, família. Lisboa: Imprensa de Ciências Sociais. Google Scholar | |
| Amaral, AL, Moita, G (2004) Como se faz (e se desfaz) o Armário: Algumas representações da homossexualidade no Portugal de hoje. In: Cascais, FL (ed.) Indisciplinar a Teoria: Estudos Gays, lésbicos e queer. Lisbon: Fenda, pp. 99–115. Google Scholar | |
| Arán, M, Corrêa, MV (2004) Sexualidade e Política na Cultura Contemporânea: O reconhecimento social e jurídico do casal homossexual. Physis: Revista de Saúde Colectiva 14(2): 329–341. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Assembleia da República (2009) Diário da Assembleia da República. I Series no. 002 Google Scholar | |
| Assembleia da República (2010) Diário da Assembleia da República. I Series no. 020 Google Scholar | |
| BE – Bloco de Esquerda (1999) Projecto de lei n.° 45/VIII: Altera a lei n.° 135/99, de 28 de Agosto. Diário da Assembleia da República. II Series A no.° 10 Google Scholar | |
| Brandão, AM (2007) ‘E se tu fosses um rapaz?’ Homo-erotismo feminino e construção social da identidade (PhD dissertation). Braga: Universidade do Minho. Google Scholar | |
| Brandão, AM (2011) Not quite women: Lesbian activism in Portugal. In: Woodward, AE, Bonvin, J-M, Renom, M (eds) Transforming Gendered Well-Being in Europe: The Impact of Social Movements. Farnham: Ashgate, pp. 151–168. Google Scholar | |
| Brooten, BJ (1996) Love Between Women: Early Christian Responses to Female Homoeroticism. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Butler, J (2002) Is Kinship Always Already Heterosexual?. Differences: A Journal of Feminist Cultural Studies 13(1): 14–44. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| CACDLG – Comissão de Assuntos Constitucionais, Direitos, Liberdades e Garantias (2010) Ofício n° 165/ XI/ 1.a – Proposta de lei no.°7/11/1a (GOV): Texto final e relatório da discussão e votação na especialidade. Available at: http://app.parlamento.pt/webutils/docs/doc.pdf?path=6148523063446f764c324679626d56304c334e706447567a4c31684a544556484c304e505453387851304644524578484c305276593356745a57353062334e4a626d6c6a6157463061585a685132397461584e7a595738764f444a69597a41324e6d49744e6d45794e4330305a6d566d4c5467774e4759744d7a41324f445132597a5269596a49314c6e426b5a673d3d&fich=82bc066b-6a24-4fef-804f-306846c4bb25.pdf&Inline=true (accessed 29 March 2010) Google Scholar | |
| Carneiro, N, Menezes, I (2007) From an oppressed citizenship to affirmative identities: Lesbian and gay political participation in Portugal. Journal of Homosexuality 53(3): 65–82. Google Scholar | Crossref | Medline | ISI | |
| Cascais, AF (2006) O Associativismo GLBT português. Revista Crítica de Ciências Sociais 76: 109–129. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Castells, M (1998) The Information Age: Economy, Society and Culture vol. II. Malden, MA and Oxford: Blackwell Publishers. Google Scholar | |
| Chauncey, G (1998) Gay New York. Actes de la Recherche en Sciences Sociales 125: 9–14. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Commaille, J, Martin, C (2001) La Repolitisation de la Famille Contemporaine. Comprendre: Revue de Philosophie et de Sciences Sociales 2: 129–149. Google Scholar | |
| Conferência Episcopal Portuguesa (2009) Em favor do verdadeiro casamento. Available at: http://www.agencia.ecclesia.pt/cgi-bin/noticia.pl?id=69756 (accessed 13 November 2010) Google Scholar | |
| Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith (1986) Letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church on the Pastoral Care of Homosexual Persons. Available at: http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19861001_homosexual-persons_en.html (accessed 10 August 2010) Google Scholar | |
| Costa, J (2008) O Deus individual e o Demónio colectivo. Paper delivered at the X Congresso Luso-Afro-Brasileiro de Ciências Sociais. Braga: Universidade do Minho. Google Scholar | |
| D’Emilio, J (1983) Capitalism and gay identity. In: Snitow, A, Stansell, C, Thompson, S (eds) Powers of Desire. New York: Monthly Review. Google Scholar | |
| D’Emilio, J (1990) Gay politics and community in San Francisco since World War II. In: Duberman, M, Vicinus, M, Chauncey, G (eds) Hidden from History: Reclaiming the gay and lesbian past. New York: Meridian, pp. 456–473. Google Scholar | |
| Duggan, L (2002) The new homonormativity: The sexual politics of neoliberalism. In: Castronovo, R, Nelson, DD (eds) Materializing Democracy: Toward a revitalized cultural politics. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, pp. 175–194. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Edwards, J (2007) ‘Marriage is sacred’: The religious right’s arguments against ‘gay marriage’ in Australia’. Culture, Health & Sexuality 9(3): 247–261. Google Scholar | Crossref | Medline | ISI | |
| Eurosondagem (2010) Ficha técnica para o depósito de sondagem. Available at: http://www.erc.pt/download/YToyOntzOjg6ImZpY2hlaXJvIjtzOjQwOiJtZWRpYS9zb25kYWdlbnMvb2JqZWN0b19vZmZsaW5lLzYwLjEucGRmIjtzOjY6InRpdHVsbyI7czoxMzoiZmljaGEtdGVjbmljYSI7fQ==/ficha-tecnica Google Scholar | |
| Federação Portuguesa pela Vida (2010) Untitled. Available at: http://app.parlamento.pt/webutils/docs/doc.pdf?path=6148523063446f764c324679626d56304c334e706447567a4c31684a544556484c304e505453387851304644524578484c305276593356745a57353062334e4a626d6c6a6157463061585a685132397461584e7a595738764f5455344d6a51794e5459744d6a4e68596930305a446b354c57466c4d5463745a47497a4e6a4e694d6a59795a5745344c6e426b5a673d3d&fich=95824256-23ab-4d99-ae17-db363b262ea8.pdf&inline=true (accessed 29 March 2010) Google Scholar | |
| Ferreira, PM, Cabral, M, Villaverde (2010) Sexualidades em Portugal: Comportamentos e riscos. Lisboa: Bizâncio. Google Scholar | |
| Gameiro, OJC (1998) Do Acto à Identidade: Orientação sexual e estruturação social, unpublished master dissertation. Lisboa: Instituto de Ciências Sociais da Universidade de Lisboa. Google Scholar | |
| Gerhards, J (2010) Non-discrimination towards homosexuality: The European Union’s policy and citizens’ attitudes towards homosexuality in 27 European countries. International Sociology 25(5): 5–28. Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Harding, R (2006) ‘Dogs are “registered”, people shouldn’t be’: Legal consciousness and lesbian and gay rights. Social Legal Studies 15(4): 511–533. Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Holy See (1993) Catechism of the Catholic Church. Available at: http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/_INDEXHTM (accessed 10 August 2010) Google Scholar | |
| Jornal i (2009) Bispos lamentam chumbo do referendo. Jornal i, 28 December. Available at: http://www1.ionline.pt/conteudo/39395-bispos-lamentam-chumbo-do-referendo (accessed 23 April 2010) Google Scholar | |
| Juntos pela Vida (2010) Parecer sobre a Proposta de Lei (PPL) 7/XI/1.a (GOV): Permite o casamento civil entre pessoas do mesmo sexo. Available at: http://app.parlamento.pt/webutils/docs/doc.pdf?path=6148523063446f764c324679626d56304c334e706447567a4c31684a544556484c304e505453387851304644524578484c305276593356745a57353062334e4a626d6c6a6157463061585a685132397461584e7a595738764f4455335a6a5a694d7a59745a5442695a5330304e4445354c57466a4d5745745a6a59774e5441354e6d5530596a6b774c6e426b5a673d3d&fich=857f6b36-e0be-4419-ac1a-f605096e4b90.pdf&Inline=true (accessed 29 March 2010) Google Scholar | |
| Lannutti, PJ (2005) For better or worse: Exploring the meanings of same-sex marriage within the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered community. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 22(5): 5–18. Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Marques, C, Tavares, M, Magalhães, MJ (2002) Políticas e família: Orientações legislativas em Portugal nos últimos anos. Actas do Colóquio Internacional ‘Família, Género e Sexualidade nas Sociedades Contemporâneas’. Lisboa: Associação Portuguesa de Sociologia. Google Scholar | |
| Miskolci, R (2007) Pânicos morais e controle social: Reflexões sobre o casamento gay. Cadernos Pagu 28: 101–128. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Nicol, N, Smith, M (2008) Legal struggles and political resistance: Same-sex marriage in Canada and the USA. Sexualities 11(6): 667–687. Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Pais, JM (1998) Vida amorosa e sexual. In: Pais, JM (ed.) Gerações e Valores na Sociedade Portuguesa Contemporânea. Lisboa: Instituto de Ciências Sociais da Universidade de Lisboa, pp. 407–463. Google Scholar | |
| PCP – Partido Comunista Português (1997) Projecto de lei n.° 384/VII: Estabelece protecção adequada às famílias em união de facto. Diário da Assembleia da República II series A no. 53 Google Scholar | |
| PEV – Partido Ecologista Os Verdes (1997) Projecto de lei n.° 338/VII: Alarga os direitos dos membros da família em união de facto. Diário da Assembleia da República II Series A no. 42 Google Scholar | |
| Plataforma Cidadania e Casamento (2010) Celebração do casamento entre pessoas do mesmo sexo: A proposta de Lei 7/XI. Available at: http://app.parlamento.pt/webutils/docs/doc.pdf?path=6148523063446f764c324679626d56304c334e706447567a4c31684a544556484c304e505453387851304644524578484c305276593356745a57353062334e4a626d6c6a6157463061585a685132397461584e7a595738764d6a6c68595445314f446774597a63314e5330304e3245784c5467304d7a67744e545535596a457a4e57466b4e6a41354c6e426b5a673d3d&fich=29aa1588-c755-47a1-8438-559b135ad609.pdf&Inline=true (accessed 29 March 2010) Google Scholar | |
| Platero, R (2007) Love and the state: Gay marriage in Spain. Feminist Legal Studies 15: 329–340. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| PS – Partido Socialista (2000) Projecto de lei n.° 105/VIII: Adopta medidas de protecção das pessoas que vivam em economia comum. Diário da Assembleia da República II Series A no. 23 Google Scholar | |
| PS – Partido Socialista (1999) Projecto de lei n.° 6/VIII: Altera a lei n.° 135/ 99, de 28 de Agosto (adopta medidas de protecção da união de facto). Diário da Assembleia da República II Series A no. 002 Google Scholar | |
| PSD – Partido Social Democrata (2010) Projecto de lei 119/XI: Cria e confere protecção jurídica às uniões civis registadas entre pessoas do mesmo sexo. Diário da Assembleia da República II Series A no. 21 Google Scholar | |
| Richardson, D (2000) Claiming citizenship? Sexuality, citizenship and lesbian/feminist theory. Sexualities 3(2): 255–272. Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | |
| Richardson, D (2005) Desiring sameness? The rise of neoliberal politics of normalisation. Antipode 37(3): 515–535. Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI | |
| Rimmerman, CA, Wilcox, C (2007) The Politics of Same-Sex Marriage. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Rios, RR (2006) Para um direito democrático da sexualidade. Horizontes Antropológicos 26: 71–100. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Roy, MA (2002) Le Partenariat Civil, d’un continent à l’autre. Revue Internationale de Droit Comparé 54(3): 759–786. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Santos, AC (2004) ‘Nem menos, nem mais, direitos iguais’: A juridificação do movimento LGBT português. Paper delivered at: the VIII Congresso Luso-Afro-Brasileiro de Ciências Sociais. Coimbra: Universidade de Coimbra. Google Scholar | |
| Santos, AC (2005) A Lei do Desejo: Direitos humanos e minorias sexuais em Portugal. Porto: Afrontamento. Google Scholar | |
| Santos, AC (2006) Sexual orientation in Portugal: Towards emancipation. In: Sousa Santos, B, Arriscado Nunes, J (eds) Reinventing Democracy: Grassroots movements in Portugal. London: Routledge, pp. 159–190. Google Scholar | |
| Santos, AC (2009) Molduras públicas de performatividade queer e representação mediática em Portugal. Ex-aequo 20: 97–112. Google Scholar | |
| Santos, AC, Fontes, F (2002) Descobrindo o arco-íris: identidades homossexuais em Portugal. Actas do IV Congresso Português de Sociologia. Lisboa: Associação Portuguesa de Sociologia. Google Scholar | |
| Scheingold, S (1989) Constitutional rights and social change: Civil rights in perspective. In: McCann, MW, Houseman, GL (eds) Judging the Constitution: Critical Essays on Judicial Lawmaking. New York: Scott, Foresman and Company, pp. 73–91. Google Scholar | |
| Schmitt, MT, Lehmiller, JJ, Walsh, AL (2007) The role of heterosexual identity threat in differential support for same-sex ‘civil unions’ versus ‘marriages’. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 10(4): 443–455. Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Seidman, S (2004) Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life. New York: Routledge. Google Scholar | |
| Silva C (2010) Discourse of promulgation of the law legalising same-sex marriage (20 May). Video retrieved from: http://www.presidencia.pt/?idc=21&idi=41152 (accessed 20 May 2010) Google Scholar | |
| Skivenes, M (2010) Judging the child’s best interest: Rational reasoning or subjective presumptions?. Acta Sociologica 53: 339–353. Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Smith, M (2010) Gender politics and the same-sex marriage debate in the United States. Social Politics 17(1): 1–28. Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI | |
| Smith, TW (2011) Cross-national differences in attitudes towards homosexuality. GSS Cross-national Report no. 31. Chicago, IL: NORC/University of Chicago. Google Scholar | |
| Waites, M (2009) Critique of ‘sexual orientation’ and ‘gender identity’ in human rights discourse: Global queer politics beyond the Yogyakarta Principles. Contemporary Politics 15(1): 137–156. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Weeks, J (1990) Coming Out: Homosexual Politics in Britain from the Nineteenth Century to the Present. London: Quartet Books. Google Scholar | |
| Weeks, J (1998) The sexual citizen. Theory, Culture & Society 15(3/4): 35–52. Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI | |
| Weeks, J (2007) The World We Have Won. Abingdon: Routledge. Google Scholar | |
| Wilson, AR (2009) The ‘neat’ concept of sexual citizenship: A cautionary tale for human rights discourse. Contemporary Politics 15(1): 73–85. Google Scholar | Crossref | |
| Yarhouse, MA, Nowacki, SK (2007) The many meanings of marriage: Divergent perspectives seeking common ground. The Family Journal 15(1): 36–45. Google Scholar | SAGE Journals |
