Investigating the Tenant Selection Practices of Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Landlords on Long Island
Abstract
Landlords are powerful vectors of residential sorting, opening up or constraining access to stable housing, neighborhood choice, and social opportunity. Although previous research has explored how landlords’ behaviors shape housing outcomes, existing research has not investigated the tenant selection practices of accessory dwelling unit (ADU) property owners. We conducted in-depth, semi-structured interviews with 25 ADU owner-occupiers on Long Island who rent out their units and found that ADU landlords exercised a high level of discretion when selecting tenants, some of which were rooted in race, ethnic, class, and gender-based biases. We further found that the legal status of an ADU can empower tenants and scramble typical power relations observed in landlord-tenant relationships. Furthermore, the legal status of a unit can empower neighbors to become powerful actors in tenant selection. Our research highlights how individual behaviors and the prevailing regulatory context interact to harden social inequalities in the rental market.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
American Planning Association. N.d. Accessory Dwelling Units. Chicago, IL: American Planning Association. (https://www.planning.org/knowledgebase/accessorydwellings/).
An Brian Y, Jakabovics Andrew, Orlando Anthony W., Rodnyansky Seva, Son Eunjee. 2024. “Who Owns America? A Methodology for Identifying Landlords’ Ownership Scale and the Implications for Targeted Code Enforcement.” Journal of the American Planning Association 90: 627–41.
Anacker Katrin B., Niedt Christopher. 2023. “Classifying Regulatory Approaches of Jurisdictions for Accessory Dwelling Units: The Case of Long Island.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 43:60–80.
Bartram Robin. 2022. Stacked Decks: Building Inspectors and the Reproduction of Urban Inequality. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Benjamin Ruha. 2019. Race after Technology: Abolitionist Tools for the New Jim Code. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Boeing Geoff, Besbris Max, Schachte Ariela, Kuk John. 2021. “Housing Search in the Age of Big Data: Smarter Cities or the Same Old Blind Spots?” Housing Policy Debate 31:112–26.
Bonnet Francois, Pollard Julie. 2021. “Tenant Selection in the Private Rental Sector of Paris and Geneva.” Housing Studies 36:1427–45.
Chapple Karen, Wegmann Jake, Nemirow Alison, Dentel-Post Colin. 2011. Yes in My Backyard: Mobilizing the Market for Secondary Units. Berkeley, CA: University of California Transportation Center. (https://escholarship.org/uc/item/6fz8j6gx)
Choi Ann, Winslow Olivia, Herbert Keith. 2019, November 17. “Long Island Divided.” Newsday. (https://projects.newsday.com/long-island/real-estate-agents-investigation/).
Cook Taylor Michelle, Rongerude Jane, Mueller Elisabeth, Kuhlmann Daniel. 2024. “Providing Rental Housing: A Systematic Literature Review of Residential Rental Property Owner Decision Making.” Journal of Planning Literature 39: 535–47.
Creswell John W. 2013. Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing among Five Approaches. New Delhi, India, Sage.
Decker Nathaniel. 2021. “Affordable Housing Without Public Subsidies: Rent-Setting Practices in Small Rental Properties.” Journal of the American Planning Association 87:62–72.
Decker Nathaniel. 2023. “How Landlords of Small Rental Properties Decide Who Gets Housed and Who Gets Evicted.” Urban Affairs Review 59:170–99.
DeLuca Stefanie, Rosen Eva. 2022. “Housing Insecurity among the Poor Today.” Annual Review of Sociology 48:343–71.
Desmond Matthew. 2016. Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City. New York: Crown.
Dunn Eric, Grabchuk Marina. 2010. “Background Checks and Social Effects: Contemporary Residential Tenant-screening Problems in Washington State.” Seattle Journal for Social Justice 9:319.
Ellen Ingrid G. 2020. “What Do We Know about Housing Choice Vouchers?” Regional Science and Urban Economics 80:103380.
Etikan Ilker, Musa Sulaiman Abubakar, Alkassim Rukayya Sunusi. 2016. “Comparison of Convenience Sampling and Purposive Sampling.” American Journal of Theoretical and Applied Statistics 5:1–4.
Evans Douglas N., Blount-Hill Kwan-Lamar, Cubellis Michelle A. 2019. “Examining Housing Discrimination across Race, Gender and Felony History.” Housing Studies 34:761–78.
Flage Alexandre. 2018. “Ethnic and Gender Discrimination in the Rental Housing Market: Evidence from a Meta-analysis of Correspondence Tests, 2006–2017.” Journal of Housing Economics 41:251–73.
Fonseca Manuel BC BF., Fernando A.F. Ferreira, Wenchang Fang, Jalali Marjan, S. 2018. “Classification and Selection of Tenants in Residential Real Estate: a Constructivist Approach.” International Journal of Strategic Property Management 22:1–11.
Freeman Lance. 2012. “The Impact of Source of Income Laws on Voucher Utilization.” Housing Policy Debate 22:297–318.
Garboden Philip M. E. 2023. “Amateur Real Estate Investing.” Journal of Urban Affairs 45:1081–1100.
Garboden Philip M. E., Rosen Eva. 2018. “Talking to Landlords.” Cityscape 20:281–91.
Gilderbloom John I. 1985. “Social Factors Affecting Landlords in the Determination of Rent.” Urban Life 14:155–79.
Goodman Leo A. 2011. “Comment: On Respondent-driven Sampling and Snowball Sampling in Hard-to Populations and Snowball Sampling Not in Hard-to Populations.” Sociological Methodology 41:347–53.
Greenberg Julia, Phalen Hannah, Chapple Karen, Garcia David, Alameldin Muhammad. 2022. ADUs for All: Breaking Down Barriers to Racial and Economic Equity in Accessory Dwelling Unit Construction. Oakland, CA: Terner Center for Housing Innovation and Center for Community Innovation.
Greif Meredith. 2022. Collateral Damages: Landlords and the Urban Housing Crisis. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
Greif Meredith. 2018. “Regulating Landlords: Unintended Consequences for Poor Tenants.” City & Community 17:658–74.
Hanson Andrew, Hawley Zackary, Taylor Ann. 2011. “Subtle Discrimination in the Rental Housing Market: Evidence from E-mail Correspondence with Landlords.” Journal of Housing Economics 20:276–84.
Hare Patrick H. 1985. “Accessory Apartments: Who Can Afford to Market the Concept? Generations: Journal of the American Society on Aging 9:43–45.
Huennekens Joseph W. 2021. “The Second Coming of the ADU.” Metropolitics. (https://metropolitics.org/IMG/pdf/met-huennekens.pdf).
Johnson John, Rowlands Timothy. 2012. “The Interpersonal Dynamics of In-depth Interviewing. Pp. 99–114 in The SAGE Handbook of Interview Research: The Complexity of the Craft, 2 ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University. 2023. The State of the Nation’s Housing 2023. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Graduate School of Design, Harvard Kennedy School.
Korver-Glenn Elizabeth, Bartram Robin, Besbris Max. 2023. “Housing Market Intermediaries.” Pp. 191–202 in The Sociology of Housing. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Korver-Glenn Elizabeth. 2018. “Compounding Inequalities: How Racial Stereotypes and Discrimination Accumulate across the Stages of Housing Exchange.” American Sociological Review 83:627–56.
MacQueen Kathleen M., Eleanor McLellan, Kelly Kay, Bobby Milstein. 1998. “Codebook Development for Team-Based Qualitative Analysis.” Cam Journal 10:31–36.
Marantz Nicholas J., Elmendorf Christopher S., Kim Youjin B. 2023. “Where Will Accessory Dwelling Units Sprout Up When a State Lets Them Grow? Evidence From California.” Cityscape 25:107–18.
McClure Kirk, Schwartz Alex. 2021. “Movement Toward High Opportunity and Racial and Ethnic Integration for Hispanics in the Housing Choice Voucher Program.” Cityscape 23:137–60.
McElroy Erin, Vergerio Manon. 2022. “Automating Gentrification: Landlord Technologies and Housing Justice Organizing in New York City Homes.” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 40:607–26.
McLaughlin Brenna R. 2018. “# AirbnbWhileBlack: Repealing the Fair Housing Act’s Mrs. Murphy Exemption to Combat Racism on Airbnb.” Wisconsin Law Review: 149–86.
Messamore Andrew. 2023. “The Institutionalization of Landlording: Assessing Transformations in Property Ownership Since the Great Recession.” (https://ssrn.com/abstract=4480068 or https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4480068).
Mukhija Vinit. 2022. Remaking the American Dream: The Informal and Formal Transformation of Single-family Housing Cities. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
New York State Department of State. N.d. Plus One ADU Program. New York: New York State Department of State (https://hcr.ny.gov/adu).
Niedt Christopher, Anacker Katrin B., Levy Lawrence. 2016. Accessory Dwellings on Long Island: An Overview. New York: Hofstra University Suburban Studies Center.
Ondrich Jan, Stricker Alex, Yinger John. 1999. “Do Landlords Discriminate? The Incidence and Causes of Racial Discrimination in Rental Housing Markets.” Journal of Housing Economics 8:185–204.
Pattillo Mary. 2013. “Housing: Commodity Versus Right.” Annual Review of Sociology 39:509–31.
Peterson Iven. 1988. “The Region; Subdividing the Single-family House.” New York Times, July 24. (https://www.nytimes.com/1988/07/24/weekinreview/the-region-subdividing-the-single-family-house.html).
Power Emma R., Gillon Charles. 2022. “Performing the ‘Good Tenant’.” Housing Studies 37:459–82.
Reosti Anna. 2020. ““We Go Totally Subjective”: Discretion, Discrimination, and Tenant Screening in a Landlord’s Market.” Law & Social Inquiry 45:618–57.
Reosti Anna. 2021. “The Costs of Seeking Shelter for Renters with Discrediting Background Records.” City & Community 20:235–59.
Reosti Anna. 2018. “Tenant Screening and Fair Housing in the Information Age.” Dissertation. University of Washington. (https://digital.lib.washington.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/f7e8210c-8e8b-46fe-8458-4254c8403d4f/content)
Rita Nathalie, Garboden Philip M. E., Darrah-Okike Jennifer. 2023. ““You Have to Prove That You’re Homeless”: Vulnerability and Gatekeeping in Public Housing Prioritization Policies.” City & Community 22:83–104.
Rosen Eva. 2020. The Voucher Promise”: Section 8” and the Fate of an American Neighborhood. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Rosen Eva. 2014. “Rigging the Rules of the Game: How Landlords Geographically Sort Low–income Renters.” City & Community 13:310–40.
Rosen Eva, Garboden Philip M. E., Cossyleon Jennifer E. 2021. “Racial Discrimination in Housing: How Landlords Use Algorithms and Home Visits to Screen Tenants.” American Sociological Review 86:787–822.
Rudel Thomas K. 1984. “Household Change, Accessory Apartments, and Low Income Housing in Suburbs.” The Professional Geographer 36:174–81.
Shiffer-Sebba Doron. 2020. “Understanding the Divergent Logics of Landlords: Circumstantial Versus Deliberate Pathways.” City & Community 19:1011–37.
So Wonyoung. 2023. “Which Information Matters? Measuring Landlord Assessment of Tenant Screening Reports.” Housing Policy Debate 33:1484–1510.
Stacy Christina, Noble Eleanor, Morales-Burnett Jorge, Lo Lydia 2020. Designing Accessory Dwelling Unit Regulations. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
Tighe J. Rosie, Hatch Megan E., Mead Joseph. 2017. “Source of Income Discrimination and Fair Housing Policy.” Journal of Planning Literature 32:3–15.
Walsh James D. 1999. “Reaching Mrs. Murphy: A Call for Repeal of the Mrs. Murphy Exemption to the Fair Housing Act.” Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review 34:605.
Wegmann Jake, Chapple Karen. 2012. “Understanding the Market for Secondary Units in the East Bay.” (https://escholarship.org/content/qt9932417c/qt9932417c.pdf)
Volker Jamey M. B., Handy Susan. 2023. “Exploring homeowners’ openness to building accessory dwelling units in the Sacramento metropolitan area.” Journal of the American Planning Association 89(1):45–60.
Westchester Residential Opportunities. 2022 January 27. “RE: Joint Legislative Budget Hearing on Housing: Accessory Dwelling Unit Act of 2022. Westchester Residential Opportunities.” (https://www.nysenate.gov/sites/default/files/westchester_residential_opportunities_22.pdf).
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published online: January 19, 2025
Keywords
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Article usage*
Total views and downloads: 108
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 0
Crossref: 0
There are no citing articles to show.
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
I am signed in as:
View my profileSign out
I can access personal subscriptions, purchases, paired institutional access and free tools such as favourite journals, email alerts and saved searches.
loading institutional access options
ASA members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
ASA members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
